Comments on: German wines and the Rieslings that make them. – Episode #70 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/ Wine news, tastings and reviews from the Wine Library Sun, 22 Nov 2009 04:14:44 -0800 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: John J. http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-684977 John J. Wed, 16 Sep 2009 00:38:41 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-684977 great episode Gary, but 1 thing, and I'm sure you've heard this by now but:trockenbeerenaulese comes After eiswein, not before. The oechsle [sugar ripeness scale} for eiswein is the same as beerenauslese, which is 110-128 degrees. the difference is, beerenauslese has been affected with edelfaule [noble rot] where as the eiswein grapes have not. Trockenbeerenauslese is even higher on the oechsle scale at 150-154 degrees, courtesy of further sugar concentration due to edelfaule. Although, I expect to see in a soon future episode, you bringing up this fact or mentioning that you received emails telling you this already. Still a great episode thoough, thanks Gary. so the qotd: never really followe ratings even tho I will read the magazines that use them. Just like I never cared what was the most popular record or tv show out. So, I guess it would be you without kissing ass, so long as you keep seeming to not kiss any companies or wineries ass but your own. & while I'm here, How about a vin jaune or charbono episode/tasting, really wondering what you would have to say. great episode Gary, but 1 thing, and I’m sure you’ve heard this by now but:trockenbeerenaulese comes After eiswein, not before. The oechsle [sugar ripeness scale} for eiswein is the same as beerenauslese, which is 110-128 degrees. the difference is, beerenauslese has been affected with edelfaule [noble rot] where as the eiswein grapes have not. Trockenbeerenauslese is even higher on the oechsle scale at 150-154 degrees, courtesy of further sugar concentration due to edelfaule. Although, I expect to see in a soon future episode, you bringing up this fact or mentioning that you received emails telling you this already. Still a great episode thoough, thanks Gary.
so the qotd: never really followe ratings even tho I will read the magazines that use them. Just like I never cared what was the most popular record or tv show out. So, I guess it would be you without kissing ass, so long as you keep seeming to not kiss any companies or wineries ass but your own. & while I’m here, How about a vin jaune or charbono episode/tasting, really wondering what you would have to say.

]]> By: Georges http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-459116 Georges Mon, 18 Aug 2008 16:31:18 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-459116 Dear Gary, Please take a master class in German wines before going on air again; it's not only your pronounciation that needs polishing, by the way. If you intend to educate, make sure you know the subject inside out. You clearly shy away from trying to explain the essence of German wines. You might be a celebrity but that doesn't make you a wine expert, although you will convince many a wine novice who will fall for your assertiveness. Pity - we can help. Dear Gary,
Please take a master class in German wines before going on air again; it’s not only your pronounciation that needs polishing, by the way. If you intend to educate, make sure you know the subject inside out. You clearly shy away from trying to explain the essence of German wines. You might be a celebrity but that doesn’t make you a wine expert, although you will convince many a wine novice who will fall for your assertiveness. Pity – we can help.

]]> By: The Fanjestic http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-220297 The Fanjestic Sun, 10 Feb 2008 22:45:54 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-220297 Trust WS & GV the most and WE the least. But if used as a guide, the reviewers are great, used as the bible - well that's just horrible! Trust WS & GV the most and WE the least. But if used as a guide, the reviewers are great, used as the bible – well that’s just horrible!

]]> By: Scott http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-178936 Scott Fri, 28 Dec 2007 02:28:31 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-178936 Great episode: highly informative. I knew all the terms before but did not really realize their significance. Thanks. I think the similarities are far more common than the differences between different reviewers so I don't have a favorite or least favorite. You're not too bad I guess. ;-) Great episode: highly informative. I knew all the terms before but did not really realize their significance. Thanks.

I think the similarities are far more common than the differences between different reviewers so I don’t have a favorite or least favorite. You’re not too bad I guess. ;-)

]]> By: Kristen http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-178850 Kristen Thu, 27 Dec 2007 23:43:13 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-178850 I was always confused by the German ratings. Really informative episode. QOTD: I really don't listen to reviewers. I only bought my first Wine Spectator magazine this weekend. And I listen to your tasting notes, not just your scores. I preach the Gary gospel- trust your own palette! I was always confused by the German ratings. Really informative episode.

QOTD: I really don’t listen to reviewers. I only bought my first Wine Spectator magazine this weekend. And I listen to your tasting notes, not just your scores. I preach the Gary gospel- trust your own palette!

]]> By: WA Ambassador http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-110206 WA Ambassador Fri, 31 Aug 2007 22:14:46 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-110206 Riesling is my favorite white wine. Thanks for doing an episode on it. My favorite riesling that I have ever had was a 2005 ST. M. It's from Chateau St. Michelle, but it was imported from Germany. I brought it to Christmas dinner along with one a 2005 riesling from Columbia Crest. There was no comparison! The St. M was off the chart and was massively a better wine than the CC. I couldn't believe the dramatic difference that you could taste between them. The St. M was smooth, fruity, and sweet, while the CC was dry, lots of tannin and not very good flavor. For about $12, you can't go wrong with the ST. M. Riesling is my favorite white wine. Thanks for doing an episode on it. My favorite riesling that I have ever had was a 2005 ST. M. It’s from Chateau St. Michelle, but it was imported from Germany. I brought it to Christmas dinner along with one a 2005 riesling from Columbia Crest. There was no comparison! The St. M was off the chart and was massively a better wine than the CC. I couldn’t believe the dramatic difference that you could taste between them. The St. M was smooth, fruity, and sweet, while the CC was dry, lots of tannin and not very good flavor. For about $12, you can’t go wrong with the ST. M.

]]> By: Eric Nyeste http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-108913 Eric Nyeste Thu, 30 Aug 2007 01:58:26 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-108913 We were half-expecting another scavenger hunt. To answer your QOTD: You are perfect to trust for many reasons. Primarily: You profit from wine sales (clean motive) and you tell us not to trust you (and trust ourselves). Robert Parker is a sham. We were half-expecting another scavenger hunt. To answer your QOTD:

You are perfect to trust for many reasons. Primarily: You profit from wine sales (clean motive) and you tell us not to trust you (and trust ourselves).

Robert Parker is a sham.

]]> By: David Canada http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-88583 David Canada Tue, 03 Jul 2007 18:57:39 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-88583 I love seeing you pronounce all of the german names....killer QOTD - Favorite - Neal Martin Least Favorite - Parker, specifically on California and australia. I have tried more parker 90's from those areas that were overoaked fruitbombs then I care to talk about. he needs to stick to Bordeaux and Rhone. I love seeing you pronounce all of the german names….killer
QOTD – Favorite – Neal Martin
Least Favorite – Parker, specifically on California and australia. I have tried more parker 90’s from those areas that were overoaked fruitbombs then I care to talk about. he needs to stick to Bordeaux and Rhone.

]]> By: James Leviton http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-87558 James Leviton Sun, 01 Jul 2007 22:43:12 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-87558 I have enjoyed the episodes I have watched so far. However, I think you concentrate on wines that are too expensive. I sure cannot afford $50 to $100 bottles of California cabernet; I cannot afford $35 bottles of German Riesling either. What I am interested in are bottles of wine priced at $20 or less which taste like a much more expensive wine. I have enjoyed the episodes I have watched so far.

However, I think you concentrate on wines that are too expensive.

I sure cannot afford $50 to $100 bottles of California cabernet; I cannot afford $35 bottles of German Riesling either.

What I am interested in are bottles of wine priced at $20 or less which taste like a much more expensive wine.

]]> By: Mark L http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/comment-page-2/#comment-80002 Mark L Wed, 13 Jun 2007 18:18:13 +0000 http://tv.winelibrary.com/2006/08/14/german-wines-and-the-rieslings-that-make-them/#comment-80002 Gary, I wasn't going to be as harsh as Tom, but I second the motion - Learn some basic German pronunciation. 85-90% of my cellar is German wines. Also, you didn't comment on longevity. Yes, it's fun to taste and drink young wines, but some wines that were marginal when young aged into truly regal beauties. Other than tastings, I seldom drink a Riesling until it is 5-7 years old. Gary, I wasn’t going to be as harsh as Tom, but I second the motion – Learn some basic German pronunciation. 85-90% of my cellar is German wines. Also, you didn’t comment on longevity. Yes, it’s fun to taste and drink young wines, but some wines that were marginal when young aged into truly regal beauties. Other than tastings, I seldom drink a Riesling until it is 5-7 years old.

]]>