Pinot Noir Showdown – Episode #418

February 28, 2008

Continuing with the head to head showdown today Gary compares 2 Pinot Noir’s when something totally unexpected happens.

Having trouble viewing this video? Try the Quicktime version.

Comments on this episode(271) Leave a comment ›

“QOTD: Marques De La Concordia 2005 Rioja Reserva, perfect new world fr…” by richardvinifera
“I haven’t thought about Quick in a long long time. I haven’t even had…” by ulu ulu ulu ulu
View all 271 ›

Wines tasted in this episode:

2006 Amisfield Pinot Noir Central OtagoNew Zealand Pinot Noir
2005 Phillips Hill Toulouse Pinot NoirOther California Pinot Noir

Links mentioned in todays episode.

Phillips Hills Estates Contact Info

271 Responses

February 28, 2008

Palmer
#1?
February 28, 2008

abqdeb
2? is that possible? I’ve been waiting for the PN show!
February 28, 2008

GrapeStuff
top 5
February 28, 2008

Joe
wow #3 Gary I think you should have waited till march to do battle week, I mean come on College March Madness / Wine Library TV March Madness. All the vayniacs could fill out bracket sheets and we could have tournament pools…. good idea. think about it.
February 28, 2008

crank
I’m in.
February 28, 2008

Dave
$8.3 mil?
February 28, 2008

grape_ape
top 10!
February 28, 2008

Susan
Gary-PN???? HHuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuummmmmmmmmmmm…………………………..
February 28, 2008

angryphoton
top 10 – wohoo- plus my fav varietal (hey i liked it even way before sideways).

great show

AP
February 28, 2008

Chris
10!
February 28, 2008

Chris
Central Otago Pinot Noir is really good- went to NZ a few months ago and was blown away. They really bring the THUNDER!!!!
February 28, 2008

GregStefos
Within 20, Looks like a great subject. Now to watch…
February 28, 2008

JeffK
Wow great match-up episode Gary! I’m going to have to try some of that Phillips Hill Pinot!

QOTD: The most memorable knockout I had was the 2003 El Nido – the big daddy (thus my gravatar). For this year, I would have to say the biggest knockout for me thus far was the 2003 Gemstone I drank for during New Years Eve dinner.
February 28, 2008

TeelaJBrown
Wow. I wouldn’t normally spring 40 bones on a wine, but your enthusiasm tells me I must.
February 28, 2008

Palmer
QOTD: can’t recall anything recently that was a revelation, although the last few NZ PNs I’ve had have all been REALLY good. very much looking forward to my Central Otago trip in August…
February 28, 2008

MattUD
QOTD: The last wine to do that to me was Educated Guess.
February 28, 2008

flynbrian
QOTD- I have never got that excited about a wine, but I’m hope it happens for me someday soon! Keep the battles going.
February 28, 2008

Jens
QOTD: Clos Saint-Jean: ChÃ¢teauneuf-du-Pape, La Combe des Fous, 2005.

Jens
from
Copenhagen
February 28, 2008

Adria
Whitcraft Pinot from Bien Nacido in the SMV ‘05. CRAZY good!
February 28, 2008

Loweeel
Top 20 again!

What, no Burgundy? No Oregon? GV, these head to heads are like division champs. We want the entire playoffs!
February 28, 2008

Marc
Love these H2H matchups GV! And love PN anyway. Gotta get my hands on these!

QOTD: It was the 1990 Tignanello. Had it in ‘98 at $120/bottle and still cannot get the amazing experience to be beaten by anything else. However, more recently I’ve been thrilled with the ‘04 Domaine Drouhin Laurene` PN.
February 28, 2008

CindyW
Why yes, I do have one of those black wrist bands. Just call me HardCoreCin.

QOTD: 2005 Cayuse Syrah Cailloux Vineyard. A wine buddy shared this with me a month or two ago, and I just waved everyone away and told them to leave me alone for a while. I think I sniffy-sniffed that glass for about 10 minutes, finding new things every with every whiff. The taste help up to the nose, and it was one of the best wines I’ve ever had. I’m on the waiting list, and have found a bottle or two via people selling off their allotment.
February 28, 2008

tom
the weirdest thing happened the last time i ordered wine from wine library — i ordered 2 bottles of Antonelli Sagrantino — and I received a single shipper with one bottle — Gary, I know your folks can’t just believe everything they hear, but it is true……
February 28, 2008

Aaron Ed
QOTD: 2003 Kunde Robusto. Just awesome!
February 28, 2008

Sonnenuhr
It’s the Eisch(pronounced Eye-sch)Breathable glasses, you nebisch. They completed change your tasting experience. Just in case, I got six boittles of the Phillips Hill.

QOTD The last bottle that blew me away like that was 1984 Spottswoode Cab that I had about a month ago. Thought it would be well past peak, but it brought the THUNDER (BIG time).
February 28, 2008

shawnandlu
Nice to see an episode where a pinot actually tastes great. I have had so many overpriced so so ones lately that I am to the point where I have stopped buying them. Curse you Sideways, but the bargin merlot was nice for a while.

QOTD: 2000 Royal Tokaji nectar of the gods!
February 28, 2008

purplejuicebruce
QOTD….Easy, Jeff Runquest Petite Sirah
February 28, 2008

Susan
Gary- 2006 Appellation Bandol Controlee La Bastide Blanche France !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Dry and fabulous!!!!! I am on the short list at my local wine shop to get more when they arrive……………………………………………………. :)
February 28, 2008

R M Kriete
But Gary, did ya like the Phillips Hill Pinot….I couldn’t really tell!
February 28, 2008

Michael Y
qotd ‘05 bordeaux tasting.
February 28, 2008

e.fremont
Lovin’ the matchups! QOTD: Elyse Grenache blend, good stuff.
February 28, 2008

Oklahoma Michael
Last wine that knocked me out was 1999 Dom. Pegeau. AS a matter o’ fact I had it last Sunday, and I am still knocked out by it.
February 28, 2008

Bruce
QOTD – Last wine that did that for me was the 2001 Pegasus Bay Prima Donna Pinot Noir that I had with a lunch at the winery near Christchurch, NZ. My first proof that South Island NZ Pinot could be amazing.

BTW – Just ordered a half case of the Phillips Hill Pinot current release of what you reviewed on here. It’s been a while since I bought a California PN, I’ve been disappointed by them too many times in the past. Usually too much $$$, not enough thunder.
February 28, 2008

Roro
QOTD: 2001 Montes Folly Syrah. I didn’t think I even liked Syrah before I tasted this. Bought a few 04’s of this, not the same but still great!

Pinot Noir almost qualifies as desert wine for me, I don’t go there.
February 28, 2008

Taylor
Great show haven’t drank pinot in a while and would love to get on the mailing list for phillips hill.
QOTD Probably the 04 Dominus one of the best wines i’ve ever had!
February 28, 2008

Bob Sherron
QOTD: The Artesa 2003 Cab – http://corkd.com/wine/view/41383 – Had it at my cousin’s restaurant, paired with the surf and turf. Awesome experience. We ordered a second bottle, it was that perfect.
February 28, 2008

MW_DM,IA
QOTD: The last wine to really surprise me at all was one I thought would be horrible when I picked it up at the shop. Mattie’s Perch 2006 White Shiraz. It was pretty AC, but it had a familiar juice box flavor off in the distance which was kind of fun. Tasted of strawberries and a bit of pepper, and something else I couldn’t name. All in all enjoyable for the $4 bottle, but not great in any sense of the word.
February 28, 2008

SaraMHCRU
I had a Rhone at a restaurant recently that I seriously enjoyed. Don’t recall the name, but it was totally silky and delicious. I think it was my first experience with Rhone (other than Rhone style from cali) and I want to buy every one that I see now!
February 28, 2008

Joshua E.
Great show…haven’t ever had a wine that made me react that way. I hope that I do one day.
February 28, 2008

Swedish T
Great EP.
IÂ´m going to an Cali. Pinot Noir tasting in two weeks here in Sweden. I think that new world Pinot Noir with a couple of years in bottle are some of the most food friendly red wines, of all. The world of food is using more and more sugar and sweet tastes, the new world fruit is necessary.

QotD : Tasted three great modern wines from Spain yesterday that really blew me away, 04 Pintia from Toro, 03 Clos de l’Obac from Priorat and Petalos Mencia from Bierzo…

Its time to do a Bierzo episode Gary…

Swedish T
February 28, 2008

Neil
QOTD: Pappapietro Perry Pommard Clones Russian River Vallay Pinot Noir. Yummy. On another front I was lucky to find 2005 Carronne St. Gemme Haut Medoc for $13.00 that was unbelieveable at the price point. Bought a case.
February 28, 2008

mbannon
Wow, helluva match today Gary!

QOD – Tokay Escenzia. Un-freakin-believable stuff.
February 28, 2008

jason
love the pinot episode. i guess burgundy and oregon are too easy. pinot grows in strange little pockets.
QOTD: it was a 2002, gevrey chabertin, la tradition by denis bachelet. still closely kept to the chest but boy did have some potential.
gettin’ better
February 28, 2008

Chateau_Plonk
1986 Beringer Private Reserve Cabernet. I Wish Napa still made wines like this!
February 28, 2008

Panosh
I just ordered 2 bottles direct to try.

About 5 years ago I had some “j” Chardoney that was outstanding. Definately a white for a red drinker.

Thanks
February 28, 2008

Jerm
Are Eisch glasses really so uncommon? You can buy them at the corner drugstore here in Honolulu….
February 28, 2008

Jaybird
Love the head to heads! I think you just flooded the winery e-mail, I picked a bottle of each…they had another available from mendocino also. Anyway chalk one up for USA, battle royal wine olympics.

QOTD: The last wine that made me act that way was a 2006 De Lisio Australian Grenache also a $40…square that off with a spanish or a Rhone.
February 28, 2008

Erica37
Those of you who are going nuts for this Pinot Noir – check it out! Phillips Hill Estates has a profile at AmericanWinery.com, where you can rate and review wines you try! I’m sure the vintner Toby Hill will be thrilled to see your ratings! Here’s the link so you can go straight to the wine -

http://www.americanwinery.com/wine/3249/2005-Phillips_Hill_Estates-Pinot_Noir_Toulouse_Vineyard

QOTD: I’m in love with Farella-Park Vineyards 2004 Road Block Syrah!
February 28, 2008

DannInNH
Oh oh…
I watched today’s episode and thought “Oh Boy, I have to buy the Pinot from CA”. I jumped on their site, placed the order and then found out it was the ‘06 vintage, not the ‘05 reviewed today. Oh well, maybe it will be just as good.
QOTD: A Medusa Old Vin Zin that was just super after dinner.
February 28, 2008

Johan
Thank’s for a great episode, I’ve got to find that one.
QOD, either 2002 Richebourg Dom. A_F Gros or, 2004 Donnafugata Ben RyÃ© Passito de Pantelleria.
The last one actually made me cry.
Nice to see you again Gary.
February 28, 2008

Mark
2004 Whitehall Lane Cabernet Sauvignon Silver Anniversary Reserve
February 28, 2008

Phil G
QOTD – the last time I remember feeling like that was for a Kaesler Stonehorse 2005 Barossa GSM…
February 28, 2008

Kev and Ams
QOTD: One of the Pinots in your secret pack. T-Day I think.
February 28, 2008

Sassodoro
QOTD. I’m not sure that I ever have reacted quite like that. Close maybe.
February 28, 2008

cameron w
QOTD – Probably either Four Vines Anarchy or Eos Reserve Petit Sirah. Bruisers both, but lately I’ve been in the mood for bruisers. Good show, I actually like the fact that it wasn’t OR vs Burgundy which is what I tend to think of for PN head to head. NZ PN is fantastic, I’ve stayed away from CA, as most CA producers wouldn’t know what to do with a PN grape if their life depended on it. But, perhaps I’ll check out today’s offering.
February 28, 2008

Nick Lewis
Avelar Pedro Ximenez Solera 1927. This was a complete surprise to me. I was expecting something sweet and got something fabulously layered. I think the key to me was the fact that it was not expensive. When you get to taste a pricey burgundy or cabernet or something, your expectations are already high, so it is harder to be blown away.

My first experience like that was in 1974 when I had a Mondavi Chardonnay and suddenly realized that there was more to this wine thing than I thought.
February 28, 2008

Bruce Hill
Arnaldo Capria Sangrantino di Montefalco 25 Ainee 1999

It changed and evolved dramatically over two hours. A religious OMG experience.
February 28, 2008

John Farrin
QOTD:
Red-2003 St. Jean du Barroux L’Oligocene-your recommendation, thank you.

White-2005 Nugan ‘Frasca’s Lane’ Chardonnay King Valley, Victoria, Austrailia

Phillips Hill doesn’t have anything about a mailing or waiting list on their site but they do have some 2006 Toulouse for sale.
February 28, 2008

JC
QOTD: Domaine de la Charriere Selection de Raisins Nobles Jasnieres J. Gigou
February 28, 2008

DerekH
You’ve got to do something about that German pronunciation. It’s not eeesch, it’s icesssh (ice with a shussshy sshh at the end).
February 28, 2008

Sev
Awesome show as usual. New Zealand Pinot is definitely on my list. I have not had Anderson Valley Pinot, but Handley from the Anderson Valley makes some great Chard, Pinot Gris, and Gewurz! I will have to see if they make Pinot.

QOTD: That last wine that knocked my socks off was the Quinta do Vale Meandro. The only table wine from Portugal I have ever had, but it was awesome. Had muscle, but amazing complexity, and very fine tannins on the finish.
February 28, 2008

BobbyTiger
Have had some very good wines, but nothing to completely knock my socks off, (yet).
February 28, 2008

Stacy B.
Sweet to see smaller case producing wineries get a nod and good job in their direction!

I just saw more info about this wine here:

http://www.americanwinery.com/wine/3249/2005-Phillips_Hill_Estates-Pinot_Noir_Toulouse_Vineyard
February 28, 2008

Dr T from N. Carolina
QOTD — it’s been so long, I can’t remember!
February 28, 2008

Sayle
QOTD: Hands down…Santa Barbara Winery- 2005 Santa Rita Hills La Fond GRENACHE.
A close second? Laetitia Pinot Noir (California).
February 28, 2008

Obama_Man
QOTD: ‘89 Margaux over XMas
February 28, 2008

Len
Love the pinot-noir episode… and the head to head format.QOTD There were two wines that were just killers for me 1995 Dal Forno Amarone and 1994 Shafer Hillside Select….couldn’t put the glass down.
February 28, 2008

Rick
Chateau Picoron, Cotes de Castillon, 2001: it blew me out of my socks! Expected a dull Bordeaux, but got a mind-dazzling wine (after long discussions we settles on the aroma (and taste) of boar in a mushroom sauce, but a very rich sauce. At the same time extremely elegant and strong.
February 28, 2008

Katherine
QOTD: I don’t know that I’ve ever had a reaction like that to a wine!

Love these head-to-heads. I’m learning so much from you, GV. And you should see Miss Vivian these days… sitting up like a pro, stuffing all sorts of things into her mouth. The latest foods on her palate: avocado, peas, and green beans. Yum.
February 28, 2008

xtrmtk
Love your PN reviews, we have the same tastes in cold region wines.

I hope you’ve tried a few Pinot Noirs from Tasmania. If you like the Central Otago pinots, you’ll probably like the Tassie ones as well. Examples I’ve loved: Freycinet, Dalyrimple, and Stefano. Good stuff being done down there. Some of their sparklers are getting pretty nice too.
February 28, 2008

Mario Salas
QOTD: 2005 Konzelman Estate Vidal Ice Wine – Just ethereal on how the nose, body, and finish all worked in unison to “bring the thunder.” Not too sugary sweet, and not too thick or acidic, but JUST RIGHT. Also, the 2004 Mondavi Reserve Napa Valley Cabernet….smooth fruit on the nose with a velvety feel on the mouth and a LOOOOONG finish, hands down one of the best Cabernets that I have ever had.
February 28, 2008

lifestooshort
dude, seriously, who cares about wine stuff? “Hey Timmy…” the 3rd grade 30 y.o. nutjob is what we all log on for. But you knew that, right? ;D
February 28, 2008

Mike L
Great show. I love me some Pinot Noir and I’m getting on that mailing list as we speak.
February 28, 2008

JimChem
QOTD Probably a Gary Ferrell PN.
February 28, 2008

Montrose
QOTD: 1988 Corton Bressands from Domaine Chandon de Briailles. Amazing focus, minerality and acidity.
February 28, 2008

Tom G. of the CKC
Ugh, what was there only like a case of this stuff in stock?

QOTD: None that have made me react that way, yet. The closest was probably the 2003 Ramey Diamond Mountain Blend.
February 28, 2008

Josh in Burgundy
QOTD:Actually tonight I had an amazing Echezeaux Grand Cru 2002. Too bad it was a gift from a friend and the winemaker no longer makes wines, but man was it unearthly good stuff.

Thanks for the “just joshin ya” reference that I know you did just for my sake
February 28, 2008

billyg
2002 Foxen Foothills Reserve. I had one bottle summer 2007. I’m holding another for next year. It is a great mix of new world/old world style.
February 28, 2008

KVolk
QOTD: none makes me act the way you do at least not until I have drank most of it….first time I drank a opus one for a celebratory occasion maybe…

GO Honey Dog!!
February 28, 2008

thisIslandEarth
GV – good episode. I tried to buy the CA Pinot from WL but it was history only 45 comments to the wind. SO, I bought the ‘06 directly from Phillips Hill. Even though you reviewed the ‘05 I had to give it a shot. I mean the last time you were that excited about anything was when Broadway Joe was hitting on Susie Kolber during the Jets/Pats game. If Joe can wear a fur coat on the sidelines, I can spring $40 on a bottle of Pinot.
February 28, 2008

DRHamp
Really enjoyed the PN Head-to-Head.

Immediately went to the Phillips Hill web site and ordered 6 — it was not the 2005, only 2006 is available from the winery — hopefully it will be great too. Then did a search for the 2005 and found it and order 6 more — can’t wait.
Love the Head-to-Head format!
February 28, 2008

Robin C
QOTD: probably the Andretti zinfandel/primitivo – I think 2005, or the Rippon pinot noir 2002 from Otaga.
We have a couple of Amisfelds PInots 2004 that we like a lot.
February 28, 2008

James H
Best wine I ever had was 2003 Rasteau, CÃ´tes-Du-RhÃ´ne Villages. French, grenache noir, and totally awesome. I day dream about that puppy.
February 28, 2008

Shad
I’d have to say the 2005 Lily Pinot Noir was the last wine to really wow me, which is interesting because I really dig Merlot and am tired of all the Pinot-Hype. Bias does play a part.
February 28, 2008

No92
Good show, â€œHey Timmy!â€ Classic stuff. Full â€“ time Lurker first â€“ time comment. QOTD: I had an opportunity to barrel taste at Copain in March 2005. I had some of the assistant wine makeâ€™s private stash, a project he was working on, a syrah, best liquid to ever grace my PAL. Keep it up Vaynerchuk.
February 28, 2008

RonC
Very good episode. Too bad you don’t have any Phillips Hill in stock.

QOTD: Still haven’t found a wine I’ve flipped over.
February 28, 2008

Andy
QOTD—- a wine from St Joseph (2004) N Rhone WOW
February 28, 2008

Michael
QOTD:
Heissenberg Gewurztraminer – for my ‘pal’ I can’t think of any more profound wine than Gverz, although the Treana Viognier/Marsanne is a close second, both of these made me think white wine is in many ways ‘better’ than red, and it all doesn’t have to be oaky chard or lemonade.
February 28, 2008

Christine
One of the best wines I’ve ever had was a 97 Brunello di Montalcino from a producer near San Gimignano that doesn’t export. My husband and I had a taste of the either 90 or 95 Brunello from the same producer that was phenomenal as well.
February 28, 2008

Utah
It never fails, as soon as I say: Okay, I can’t buy any more wine for a while … GV goes berserk over something that sounds right up my alley. So here I am, deciding its worth $20 to fedex to not have to drive two hours to the nearest store I found with the 2005 in stock.

QOTD: Probably a 2001 Borgogno Barolo that I still have a couple bottles of stashed away for safekeeping. I can’t say that my reaction was as animated, and I wonder if I’d react as strongly to it now as I did even then, as I drank it just last year, on a night that kind of sent my wine-lust on the full throttle ride its been on for the last few months (and finding this show just after christmas dropped a brick on the gas pedal).
February 28, 2008

Dominus
I’d be curious to see if any of the Vayniacs procur any of the Toulouse. I will make a feeble attempt very soon.

QOTD: Good question but I’ll have to say it was probably an ‘85 Opus I had about a year ago.

Hey Timmy!
February 28, 2008

Robert Howells
Panther Creek Pinot Noir kicks ass. By the way, I do have one of the original wristbands so I’m feeling hardcore.
February 28, 2008

Plminer
Great show today GV, love the battle format, well done. Gotta check out those pinot’s, wow, Anderson Valley is blowing up!
QOTD: Merry Edwards Sonoma Coast PN 2005
February 28, 2008

Dave Canada
Knew that you would bring up that Raptors game………an embarrasement of a game….who is Jamal Crawford?????????
QOTD – 1990 Cos D’estournel…..blew my mind!!!!
February 28, 2008

Syrahhhhhhhhh
Awesome episode!!! I love these battles. Boomshaklaka I ordered two bottles from the winery and begged to be on the list. Thank you GVNC!

QOTD: I recently had a bottle of the 2004 Pride Merlot and it made me say the F word out loud against my will because it so good. Seriously.
February 28, 2008

C-BusWineMofo
Love Love Love the Pinot show.

QOTD: 2004 Domaine Drouhin LaurÃ¨ne
Dundee Hills one of the best places to grow Pinot and Chard in the world.
February 28, 2008

alfredhayes
QOTD: Penley Estate Phoenix Cabernet Sauvignon 2005. Had it last night on a whim at Canyon Creek and it totally blew me away.

I know you like to call it the “silk alert” but I seriously think that “liquid velvet” sounds better, and totally applies to the finish on this wine. At ~$25 CAD (if you can find it) a total steal. If you’ve experienced Peter Lehmann Shiraz, think that type of finish, but with a lot smoother attack and mid-pallet.
February 28, 2008

Syrahhhhhhhhh
As was mentioned below, they are selling the 2006 on their site, not the 2005. I bought them anyway. And they completely upped their production to a whopping 150 cases.
February 28, 2008

Marshall
QOTD: Leitz 2004 rudesheimer bischofsberg auslese
February 28, 2008

Edward Salonia
Good show today…

QOTD: 2002 Penfolds RWT Shiraz, Barossa Valley. Absolutely beautiful on my pal.
93 from Wine Spectator, and 93 from Robert Parker… Get this one the show.
February 28, 2008

lawschooldrunk
woohoo! top 100!
February 28, 2008

Peter Wood
QOTD: 2006 Crater Rim Akaroa Pinot Gris. A late harvest Pinot Gris from New Zealand, it was all marzipan, nuts, cooked butter, tangerine and pears with BEAUTIFUL minerality on the finish and stonking clean acidity. A brilliant wine.
February 28, 2008

Harley Stan
WOW great match up today I could feel the thunder.
QOTD- 2002 Arrowood Cabernet Sauvignon, I didn’t go quite that crazy but I was very happy with it so I bought a case. ( this is the first full case I have bought of any wine so it must have made an impression)
February 28, 2008

Lois and Greg
QOTD: Meerlust Rubicon in the estate’s cellar during our trip to South Africa.

Getting into the one-on-one tasting battles. Keep it up
February 28, 2008

Marc Bienvenue
hey gary it was the MASI Amarone…i,d die for it
February 28, 2008

The Original Marc
QOTD: Easy. 2002 Fairview Pinotage. I bought every bottle in the state (both of them), and they were both breathtaking. Second best wine I’ve ever had, but also cheaper than most wines I’ve had.
February 28, 2008

Kristen
You definitely got me fired up GV!

QOTD: Elizabeth Rose Pinot Blanc from Bonded Winery #9 (Also put out Napa Wine Co, and sell lots of juice to “cult” wineries unknowingly to all of those freaks paying up the wazuu for those wines- get a life and start expanding your palates kids!). What an out of body experience!
February 28, 2008

Sharon
There hasn’t been a wine in my newbie drinking career that completely surprised and knocked my socks off like the Phillips Hill evidently did to GV! Wonder if I could locate that around here… of course I looked and they can’t ship to MA, probably because we’re still Pilgrims.
February 28, 2008

amgryger
QOTD: Recently it was the Cascina Morassino ‘96 barbaresco.
February 28, 2008

Kirk (AKA: Slave2thevine)
QOTD: Wow…that’s pretty easy. 2005 Kelham Vineyard Chardonnay. I absolutely lost it when I tasted it for the first time. Great stuff for a guy that hardly owns any Chardonnay.
February 28, 2008

LB in KS
yes indeedy Petey…I do have one of those. I still can’t believe I gave my little Sis my 2nd edition though
February 28, 2008

He Lurks Hard for the Money
2004 L’Oustal Blanc Minervois NaÃ¯ck 4

Truly outstanding wine, at a steal of a price.
February 28, 2008

E-Dub
So sick of wines that I can’t get in PA!!!

QOTD: Last wine I really, really dug and couldn’t get enough of was carmenere served in a Chilean wine flight at a local tapas restuarant. I loved it so much that I’ve bought every bottle of Carmenere that I’ve come across since hoping to have the same kind of experience. The 04 Terrunyo (Concha Y Toro) did it for me too.

I cannot get into pinot noir… always seem to love the nose but find the mouth feel boring and thin. Maybe I’ll have to work around the shipping somehow to get some of this and see what the fuss is about.
February 28, 2008

Rani Haykal
Great Show!!!

QOTD: The wine that totally rocked me and left me just wanting more was the Nickel and Nickel Lightning Strikes. Its a Cab/Syrah blend which is abnormal for them being that they are single vineyard, single varietal wines. This one just happened to be a mix up and instead of scrapping it, they decided to bottle it. Incredible mouthfeel with the best of both worlds from cab and syrah varietals.

–RH
February 28, 2008

ryan
Cool format – love the thunder for the california pinot -gary’s the bomb -Mollydooker Velvet glove
February 28, 2008

NB_SPAZZ
Can’t you just picture it… GV, 80 years old at the track yelling about the horses (how none of them stack up to 1995 Kentucky Derby winner “Thunder Gulch”), wine, and his prostate!
QOTD: Haven’t had a wine knock my sox off quite like that, yet.
February 28, 2008

kaybee
I like the format. I think it kind of funny how the bottles that rock are so limited in production.

QoTd
Yes, a WA malbec was so seductive I bought a case.
February 28, 2008

Ben F
Great Show GV…
QOTD I was at a wine tasting and it was Arnoux Vacqueyras from 2004 it was Awesome…
February 28, 2008

Marty
Nice show Gary !
QOTD: recently, I had a ChÃ¢teau Lamothe 1986 from Sauternes. It was the second bottle I drank and much better than the first one I had one year ago.
February 28, 2008

The Doc
1999 San Leonardo
February 28, 2008

TROC
I had a Vero by Drouhin 02 that was close to a Hagler vs Hearns unfortunately the 2nd bottle was more like Tyson vs Spinks.
February 28, 2008

Lenny
QOTD: Never!!!!!
February 28, 2008

chenrys
Impressive show…wish we were trying those wines.

QOTD: We have a couple of wines we really like but probably not THAT much. Hope we find some though.
February 28, 2008

No Filtering
Gary,

I have generally considered it to be a negative when I find “cola” in my Pinot Noir. That and root beer and sassafras flavors, which one can seriously get in California Pinot and sometimes warm Oregon years says to be me “over-ripe” and over-extracted. Where has the delicacy gone? A generation are growing up thinking that Pinot needs to be “BIG!”

I think you’re doing a cool thing, but “raisin” in pinot noir? In old vine zinfandel or port it would add complexity, but in this case, it goes along with the “cola” note in its messaging. If you like this wine, terrific, BUT what do you think Pinot should be about? For most pinot-heads, it’s not size and richness as much as the seductive aromas and finesse that come with a long hang time and interesting soil. Too much California Pinot these days tastes like Syrah to me and the public is growing to expect that. Be sure to clarify for your viewers, Gary not only what is there, but maybe what is missing from big pinot noir. I commend what you are doing overall. I like your honesty and enthusiasm.
February 28, 2008

Anthony L.
Love the Pinot from Anderson Valley. Great episode.
February 28, 2008

Shadowbird
QOTD: A local Raspberry Merlot. I could definitely taste the raspberry, but there was just so much more there as well.
February 28, 2008

RB
Gary,
Like the battle royal…..love the color challenge as well.

QOTD: has to be the Carm….absolutely love the wine and the price….
February 28, 2008

Little Jonny H
QOTD: Nothing that has completely knocked my socks off, but I had my first bordeaux (Beaulieau comtes des tastes, 2001) that was unlike anything I’d had before. Bold, old world, and DRY -evolved for a couple days at room temp! My first tannin monster off the bat… but smoothed out very nicely. Can’t wait to open some of the 2005’s a few years down the road!
February 28, 2008

Kevin
QOTD: I do recall a particular winery where I thought ‘oh my god, what am I doing here, I can’t afford this stuff’. Domaine Pavelot, Savigny Les Beaune, Burgundy. And I’m going back, baby.
February 28, 2008

David M Roberts
Cool format with the versus thing going on.

QOTD: Justin’s “The Orphan” for the quality to value ratio.
February 28, 2008

grant
2005 Domaine de Marcoux – awesome stuff, let it decant for a couple of hours..heavenly.

Hey Gary, ever think of incorporating some kind of blind tasting into a show? I think it would be neat for you to have some bottles brown bagged and try to guess what you are sniffing and drinking. Maybe instead of brown bags, do a show blind folded. Have Vayniacs vote for what you should drink. Just some ideas.

I like this weeks format. Good stuff as always.

~g~
February 28, 2008

Paul M
QOTD: 2000 Pontet Canet
February 28, 2008

Steve
Gary,
Thanks for the review.
The Bad News:Philips Hill is out of the 2005
The Good News: They’ve up production 50% (150 cases for 06)
February 28, 2008

tuscanbob
Phillips Hill doesn’t ship to NY….aaaaaarrrrrrggggghhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anyway, the last wine that blew me away was the McPrice Myers L’Ange Rouge Grenache that you featured about a month ago. I’m a huge grenache fan and this one rocks…a big explosion of chocolate covered cherries and strawberries. Tough food pairing but who cares…it’s sooo good. I jumped all over their mailing list.
February 28, 2008

The Shooter
Gary, nice wine boobs.
February 28, 2008

David Dornback
The last knockout bottle I had was the 05 Kiana produced at Crushpad. My buddy Randy made it with help from his friends. ToKalon fruit, made in a Pride styleâ€¦.ripping good!

Sadlyâ€¦only one barrel made.
February 28, 2008

NathanN
It’s got to be the 2004 Pahlmeyer I had a couple of weeks ago.
February 28, 2008

Terp00
QOD: Bought a Foxen Bien Nacido 2005 a few weeks back. My wife and I enjoyed it immensely. It had this Root Beer or Dr Pepper that was extremely obvious, probably some clove, and some powdered cocoa. Definitely going to have to get back to the WL for a few more of those.
February 28, 2008

David L
QOTD: Mas de la dame La Stele 2001 provence region
February 28, 2008

zach even - esh
Gary – AWESOME interview with Yanik, that was his best interview EVER! U da man baby! Where are your shops in NJ? I need to get some expensive wine as we’re having a new arrival in June, and I’m gonna celebrate!!

Looking forward and stay crazy

~ zach even – esh / NJ
February 28, 2008

Nick A.
QOTD: 1990 Le Bon Pasteur.
February 28, 2008

Fred
Hehe, great series and brilliant idea.

QOTD:…I need some inspiration…Go out to find some for this afternoon.:)
February 28, 2008

Kristen
Nice episode today- it was quite thundertastic! Thanks for taping them in advance, us Vayniacs appreciate a daily dose of the Thunder!

QOTD: I’ve never had that type of reaction with a bottle of wine yet. I guess the closest I’ve had to that experience would be a white table wine from Tuscany that I had while eating at the Accademia restaurant in Florence. It was delicious and was a bit pÃ©tillant, but this could be form my frame of mind at the time!
February 28, 2008

Georgie K
i love when you feel extreme love or hate for a wine. I don’t think i’ve ever had a wine i’ve reacted that well to, but i’m still part of the CKC. I was really shocked at a recent taste of Dow’s non-vintage “Fine Tawny Port”. It taste exactly like raisins to me. i don’t like raisins.
February 28, 2008

J Hartfiel
Thank you GV. I have been really into Malbec lately. I have wondered about its characteristics and how Argn Compares to France in this match up. Looking forward to 3/29
February 28, 2008

Mark Antonio
Hmmm…just ordered some of the Toulouse from the winery – but 2006 not 2005. I’m wondering how much the vintage will change the wine and the yield is much higher as well.. certainly worth a punt anyway, thanks Gary! Last wine that blew me away – would have to be the Laughing Jack Limited Three Old Vine Moppa Grenache 2005. Amazing purity and flavour.
February 28, 2008

Glenn
GV, Love the format and you hit a sweet spot with me and Pinot that is Burgundian.
QOTD: When I tasted the 2005 Peachy Canyon Old School House Zinfandel I was blown away. And I usually don’t like Cali wines.
February 28, 2008

Martini
QOTD: 2004 Coulee de Serrant, Nicolas Joly
and 2005 Ch. Petit Gravet Aine St. Emillion Grand Cru (80% Cab Franc!)
February 28, 2008

cgatesman
Awesome! I got 3 Amisfield and many other Central Otagos. I’m with you on your opinion of them, and witnessed (tasted) them first hand!

My younger brother beat me to the punch, and already called up Phillips Hill to order. The owner told him he was in the middle of watching the show!

I called my brother up to yell at him for not including me! Anyways, he’s calling them up tomorrow morning to add a couple more bottles for me. Hopefully the 2006 vintage is comparable.

QOTD: A couple big WOW’s for me… 2005 Waterkloof Merlot Peacock Ridge and 2005 Boudreaux Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon.
February 28, 2008

Saftig
Really enjoying the match ups, good clean fun. any chance that pinot’s available after you went gaga over it? I didn’t think so.
QOTD: I always look forward to the next bottle and rarely have favorites that I go back to again and again. There’s just too much good stuff out there yet to try.
February 28, 2008

tarheel17
Gary-
I (and I’m sure most other vayniacs) really appreciate that you, once again, sat down to tape an entire week’s worth of videos! I love ending my day watching your show.
I will keep an eye out for Anderson Valley Pinots…but right now I’m kind of stocked in the PN area, so I will let someone else get the 05 Philip Hill.
Hope you’re rockin’…whatever city you’re rockin’!!
February 28, 2008

Kdawg
QOTD: actually, it was this past monday when I had the 01 Restituta Sugarille. just an amazing brunello

gary, how on earth could you do a pinot episode with no burgs, c’mon. the lack of burg love is disheartening
February 28, 2008

Tooch
for me, the last wine that left me speechless was the Domaine Leon Barral 2004 Faugeres. My first ever Faugeres, but certainly not my last…what a wine!
February 28, 2008

familydoc
QOTD: 2000 Schiavenza Barolo Kabooom, the sound of me being blown out of the water at Christmas!

This show rocked, BTW. Tuesday, Wed, and Thursday were all awsome shows and I got my red “Bring the Thunder” wrist band today. I’m cool!
February 28, 2008

Nicolas
QOTD: 1990 Salon Champagne in Magnum….

A pearl…
February 29, 2008

JonE
Mailing list fever G-Man. More pinot love, and I can’t get enough.

QOTD: Copain Hacienda Secoya Vineyard Pinot Noir-my brain was hearing that red alert siren, this was not good it was great.
February 29, 2008

ScottG
Thanks to my fellow Seattle Vayniacs, I’ve been sampling some very good wines lately. I was recently blown away by a 2003 Boudreaux Merlot and a 2005 Fall Line Cabernet Sauvignon.
February 29, 2008

lawschooldrunk
you know, Gary, “Sniffy sniff” doesn’t come across so well when you don’t say it so enthusiastically, like today’s episode.

canada dave, you gonna take that knocks comment sitting down?!

what type of taste is “pine cone city”?

ummm, gary, how can you say the red radish taste was so obvious when it took you a while to put your tongue on it?

philips hill is probably thinking, WTF is going on; our phones are ringing like crazy!

gary, instead of duck, you could’ve taken a bird from out in the hallway.

80 and at the track? Do tell!

QOTD: while not a wine, old pultney 12 year old single malt scotch really wowed me with its smoothness and subtle saltiness; achieving a delicate balance- and at a great sale price of $23.99 Bones, unbelievable!

and no, Gary, I’m not hardcore yet. I’ll have to settle with soft core.
February 29, 2008

brent
QOTD: Les GenÃªts SavenniÃ¨res by Damien Laureau 2004
February 29, 2008

Achilleas in Cyprus
Great show!

QOTD: Blown away by a 2003 Chanson Beaune Bastion Premier Cru – man that was soooo smooth
February 29, 2008

Niklas
QOTD: Hamilton Russell Pinot Noir 2005.
February 29, 2008

Naysen
QOTD: What’s the last wine that knocked me out like the 2005 Phillip Hill Toulouse?

Answer: The 2005 Toulouse. Confusing? Not really. Phillip Hill sources grapes from Toulouse. I absolutely love Anderson Valley Pinot wines. I make about 5 trips a year to visit AV, which is one of the most gorgeous, beautific micro-valleys in the world – that I’ve seen.

Last time I visited the Toulouse Estate vineyard, I had an opportunity to try a vertical tasting of their wines from 2002 through 2006, which was a barrel-sample. The 2005 vintage stood out like Gerard Depardieu’s nose, but in a distinctly good way. I loved it and bought way more bottles than I should be able to afford. To be clear, I’m talking about the 2005 Toulouse Vineyards Pinot Noir Estate bottling.

Gary, have you heard of this wine? Will you taste it on the show sometime? I think the 2006 will be stellar too from what I gathered from the barrel-tasting. The previous vintages weren’t too grand, or should I say small and pug-nosed.
February 29, 2008

sonapa
F-ing good show. Gary, do you have google maps in your dome? I live in nor-cali and most do not know that they come to play…. your earning your keep.

Great show.
February 29, 2008

Cookiedds
QOTD: The last wine that really got my attention was a Jessup Cellars 2003 Napa Valley Cabernet. I decanted it for a few hours, rebottled it and took it to dinner the night after Valentines day. We had it with a Chateaubriand from cafe Artemis in Helena, Montana. The meal was incredible, the atmosphere perfect and the wine was mind bending…….well, almost. The Jessup Cab was complex, deep, refined and had a very long finish. The sommelier at the restaurant was extremely impressed with the wine and want’s me to bring another Jessup wine to the restaurant for him to try.
February 29, 2008

thefanjestic
QoTd: 2004 Domaine De Chevalier (Rogue)
February 29, 2008

CoolHandLuke
The wine that blew me away was a Silver Oak. I forget the year but it is the wine that got me into wine.
February 29, 2008

Dan C.
QOTD: Almira Old Vines Los dos Grenache Syrah … wasn’t a 94 pointer or anything but I gave it solid 89 and it was only 7 bones! If you find some let me know and I will come to your house and steal it!

I love you Gary! cant wait for tomorrows show.
February 29, 2008

medo
I have one of these

Great show Mr. V!! I’m really searching some bargains in Pinots – esp. the SpÃ¤tburgunder from Germany.

QOTD: 2001 DÃ¶nnhoff NiederhÃ¤user HermannshÃ¶hle Riesling SpÃ¤tlese … I scored it 97 pts! Magic stuff!
February 29, 2008

dustin
2002 Coteaux du Languedoc, Domaine de Moncalmes (Les Caves de Pyrene).

95 pnts my pal
February 29, 2008

BPlague
Sheeps butt awesome description for a good cheese.

QOTD #1 Sorry unable to make it wish I could.

QOTD #2 Have not had one yet.
February 29, 2008

downtnmark
QOTD: Wines that struck me? (1) 2005 Darioush Signature Cabernet, probably one of the best wines of the vintage (not of the year), and (2) Gary Farell Russian River Pinot Noir. Each impressed me enough to go out and buy some.

Come to San Jose and I’ll open the Darioush with you.
February 29, 2008

Mandy
Ronchi Babera d’Alba. This is only like a $25 wine, but this is my price range. Nevetheless this wine was incredibly nervy and hmm… I think a little bit perfect. I could drink this wine every night and be content. I love North Berkeley Import selections, they rock it out each time, in a decent price range.
February 29, 2008

Central Coast Carl
Rosenblum 2003 Hillside Syrah. Drank my last bottle. It is going to be tough finding another $20 value like this. I guess I will have to get into my McPrice Myers a bit earlier than expected. Somebody stop me!
February 29, 2008

Justin L Ove
100 cases? That’s just wrong.

QOTD: 2004 Cliff Lede Cab Sauv. Bam.
February 29, 2008

glenn
who did you drop 39 on oh tiny one? hell, i have only put that # up a few times in my career!

Anderson Valley kicks major azz as all now know. what a great place to visit but the ride from Philo to the coast is considerable though the map makes it look like cake.

what did you do to the name Toulouse? i am going to have to rewind to catch that piece of butchery!

QotD: 05 Cali PN that sent me reeling was Brogan Cellars “My Fathers Vineyard”, also an Anderson Valley sourced Pinot. off the hook excellent.
February 29, 2008

Yoni Rabkin
QOTD: not one yet, but I haven’t drunk that many wines… yet.
February 29, 2008

YoungDave
YES I have one of the original wristbands, but you already knew that I was hardcore.

By the way- I LOVE this head-to-head format, with the same varietal produced from different regions of the world. KILLER show concept.

QOTD: I bought a Connonau from Sicily the other day, plenty of pencil shavings, burnt rubber, prune, leather(?) and some other interesting aromas and flavors…all for $10 U.S. bones. VERY happy with this unique wine and the QPR.
February 29, 2008

Klassh
QOTD: Never been that satisfied
February 29, 2008

Irina
Eisch is [aish] – in german.
QOTD: last one was Fontanafredda Serralunga d’Alba Barolo 2003 matcht with rich chocolate cheese cake.
February 29, 2008

Ryan D
QotD: Not sure if I’ve ever quite reacted like that.
February 29, 2008

Fiorentina!
Hey Gary-
I can’t really remember what the last wine was that made me have that reaction….There was a Rose from Tavel (Grandes Serres?) and the Bernardus Monterey Chardonnay.
February 29, 2008

Mike Z in SD
I tasted a 2001 Mocali Brunello di Montalcino Vignes del Raunate (which I’m told means “Vineyard of the Gophers”). It was awesome! It had me speechless. Kicked some serious butt.
February 29, 2008

Allan
QOTD – Recently tasted the Arrocal you showed in a previous episode and it blew me away considering most Spanish wine I tasted in the past were exremely rustic and dirty – this was a nice ripe red with a lot of finesse.
February 29, 2008

Donna Marie
The Pines 1852 2001 Zin from the Columbia Valley (Oregon)
February 29, 2008

Tom T.
I love the Hagler-Hearns analogy. Great episode.
QOTD – there have been many but the latest was the 2003 Sansonnet.
February 29, 2008

wedding-engagement-rings-jewelry
Domaine De Chevalier really fascinating…
February 29, 2008

Dan
Heading up today to the dog shows at Secaucus this weekend! I bunch of us plan to go to the Wine Library tomorrow afternoon to stock up for a dog fancier wine dinner we are having tomorrow night.

You’re a hit with Chow Chow dog owners!

Dan from Bardo Chows
Annapolis, Maryland
February 29, 2008

Alana
Awesome show Gary!!
I love pinot noirs, and this show just got me all hyped early on a friday morning to try some from anderson valley.
QOTD: Rombauer Chardonnay, ‘05 I believe. very smooth, excellent balance with just enough kick to it
February 29, 2008

LarryTheWineGuy
Actually I bought A Case of the 2005 Amisfield…Think It Had More Complexity and Better Mouthfeel than the 2006. As good as you are raving about the Phillips Hill I still think at $40 bones…the best combination for a Pinot Noir of Old World/New World Combined is still coming out of Willamette Valley Oregon in that Price Range. Try Some 2005 Beaux Freres Upper Terrace or One Of the Top 100 Wine Spectator Wines like at $30 2005 Erath Dundee Hills Estate Selection 91 Points Wine Spectator only 12.5% Alcohol…Mushrooms and Dirt For Days on The Nose!!. BTW The 2005 Amisfield Pinot was the #22 Wine Of The Year On Spectators 2007 Top 100 ! QOTD…. on your Recommendation the 2003 Cougar Crest Walla Walla Valley Reserve Syrah….Boy did that Wine Blow Me Away…I went On Line and bought another 6 bottles!!!
February 29, 2008

Capt M
After 400+ episodes, still some of the most fun episodes. Showdowns are fun! Pinot Noir is a lot of fun! QOTD: Majella Sparkling Shiraz, but also 1999 Chateau Musar, from Lebanon.
February 29, 2008

DFM
I like the head to head format
February 29, 2008

LauraG
2003 Francois Villard Condrieu De Poncins – I couldn’t shut up about it. Still can’t.
February 29, 2008

Scott EJ
Phillips Hill doesn’t have a mailing list, but, I’m quite sure they’re gonna need one now.

QOTD – 2002 J. Wilkes Pinot Noir, Lot ?, Bien Naciedo, CA. Redonkulous!!
February 29, 2008

Sarno
QOTD: Just about every wine we tried at Bern’s on Wednesday!
February 29, 2008

MacNPhish
QOTD: Just about all of the wines we tasted at Bern’s on Wednesday!
February 29, 2008

Carbondiamond
HI! Im new to wine library tv. Having a growing interest in wine and i find the shows great! I am catching up on episodes and wanted to ask a few questions…. How in the world can i get a wristband?!
And i want to pre order the Vayniac Cab and am not quite legal yet…. but will be in a few months… is there a way i could buy it on pre order and then wait until my birthday to ship?
February 29, 2008

Carly
Great episode! I don’t like the way those glasses look. Too wide at the top or something….like your whole face was getting swallowed in them when you took a sniffy sniff!

QOTD: A $10 Portuguese wine that I had.
February 29, 2008

Jeffrey Fredrick
QotD: Had this a couple of weeks ago and just flipped out: McHenry Vineyard 2002 Estate Pinot Noir

http://www.mchenryvineyard.com/2002Estate.htm
February 29, 2008

Chris Lavin
Pinot Battle: Comments that should be made is that Central Otago is the most southerly wine region in the world. One of the coolest as well – Long hangtime for Pinot Noir. The 2005 vintage in Anderson Valley is outstanding across the board. A definitive buy.
Can you comment on the clonal differences or do you feel that perhaps that conversation is too esoteric?
February 29, 2008

Carlitos
I guess I’m hard core… :S
February 29, 2008

missalyse
I was very pleasantly suprised by several dry German Rieslings this past Tuesday. I know that you only have great things to say about Riesling but before Tues I hadn’t found one that I liked. It’s hard to find quality and variety in the small PA state stores where I live.
February 29, 2008

peter
Amisfield= “PINECONE CITY!!!!”
February 29, 2008

dz
There have been many out of body wine experiences but a few that come to mind was the 2003 Couvent Des Jacobins, my favorite of the 12 days of Christmas. The 2003 Avaton was great and the 2005 Ghisolfi Pinay was killer. Going back a year or so, the 2003 Pontac Lynch that was in a tasting of ‘04 Bordeaux which included several 2nd growths was spectacular, for me easily the best wine of the tasting. I bought it and a couple of cases of the 05 from you guys.
February 29, 2008

joe trdinich
The last eye-opener I had was the 1999 Banfi Brunello di Montelcino. I think it was the first Brunello I had ever tasted and it was fantastic.
February 29, 2008

Jett-boy
Where’s the Burgundy???????
What do you have against Burgundy Gary?????
Sure I like my New Zealand and Oregon Pinot Noirs…
but I don’t think you’ve ever tasted any Burgundy’s, red or white!!!!
in 400+ shows… what’s the deal?
Sorry, to give you a hard time, I Love the show, but…..seriously!!!
Cj
February 29, 2008

Phil G.
QOTD: The last wine that did that to me was 2003 Diego Conterno Barolo. MIND BLOWING GOOD. The best Barolo I have ever tried and I have tried HUNDREDS. For the price vs. quality….UNBEATABLE.
February 29, 2008

NADINE
I can’t pin point it to just one, lol So I will have to think about it and get back to you, enjoy your weekend
February 29, 2008

B-727
Carly, very cool picture there.
QotD: about a month ago Miner’s Gary’s Vineyard Pinot.
February 29, 2008

DenverDarlin'
QOTD: 2004 Rhapsody 3 Syrah,Bourassa Vinyeards, Napa. Yum!
February 29, 2008

Mr.Sato
QOTD: Around Christmas I had the 2003 Felsina “Rancia” Chianti Classico. Blissfully beautiful wine. Rated 95pts by the pros and us alike. And only $35!!

man, you really made me want to drink some of that Phillips Hill Pinot Noir!!!
February 29, 2008

VinoVixen
QOTD: 03 K Vintners Lucky#7 -would love to have more….anyone have some to sell?????
February 29, 2008

Alexa
Great episode…love pinots…i would love to be able to buy wine from you guys but i live in GA, why there is a law agaist that?? never understood…

cheers!!

QOTD – i had the best champagne this past new years 1995 KRUG…
February 29, 2008

ValerieM
QOTD: It was the Graves Blanc from the x-mas pack…I just LOVED it and am trying more whites and french wines because of it!
February 29, 2008

Andy & Edie
Great show, loved to see your reaction to that last Pinot. Great references to boxing and horse racing, you really crack us up. QOTD: Just had a bottle of Forefather’s Cab with my Father-in-law that was spectacular.
February 29, 2008

Mikkel Hansen
Love the head to head too…

QOTD: Casa Patronales 2006 Pinot Noir…. I love the gentelnes of it. And got it at 10 bones a bottle ( with tax …in Denmark) anybody i danmark, get this now!!! at Holte vinlager… 250 kr. for 6 bottles!!!

Mikkel
February 29, 2008

Karl Laczko
Does Brandon know about that Phillips Hill Pinot?

This format is GOOD.

QOTD – Sorry to sing the same old song again, but Chateau Musar 1999 – even though it was 8 months ago now. A South African Chenin Blanc, Rijk’s Private Cellar 2005, came close at Christmas, definately the best white this year.
February 29, 2008

GalvezGuy
QOTD 2006 Belle VallÃ©e Pinot Noir Reserve, had it with a very well prepared duck dish. First Oregon Pinot I have had in quite a while and it reminded me of while I used to be such a huge fan. Sure 40 bones is a lot, but this one brought it.
February 29, 2008

The Wine Maven
QOTD: 2000 Derszla Aszu Eszencia from the Wine Library Bordeaux wine dinner at the Manor last week. The Derszla was a luscious dessert wine with peach, honey, and apple flavors. Knocked my socks off!
February 29, 2008

CA Jake
I have had the 05 and 06 Amisfield and liked them a lot. The Toulouse sounds amazing. Went right to their site and bought some. They don’t have a mailing list but you can buy their wine (usually its the other way around). Sounds like they also have another one “Opennlander”, that they charge a bit more for. Could it be better?
Gary, you are right on about Anderson Valley. Especially 06.
February 29, 2008

BruceP
QOTD: a 1995 Vincent Girardin burgundy from Chambertin. Can’t remember the vineyard, but it was premier cru. Outstanding stuff. That or the 2004 Walter Hansel North Slope Pinot Noir.
February 29, 2008

ChezJosh
I just tasted 100 Bordeaux. The Chateau D’Yquem certainly brought the thunder.
February 29, 2008

SoCal
QOTD: The last one was the 2001 Almaviva
February 29, 2008

Ivan C.
qotd – Alvaro Palacios 2004 Les Terrasses Priorato. Straight killer.
February 29, 2008

OmarG
Keep up the Head-to-heads! Fun!…
QOTD: Duale from Calabria, Italy…it just reminded me of when I fell in love with wine on my first trip to Italy.
February 29, 2008

JayZee
QOTD: I was just blown away by the 2001 Luzon Altos Luzon tonight. It was amazingly good. Actually, the 2004 Alvaro Palacios Les Terrasses Priorato was also silly good this past summer in Barcelona.
March 1, 2008

Matlatzinca
QOTD: 2005 Loring Cargasacchi Pinot Noir. Serious thunder, and I hear the case of 2006 in our cellar is even better!
March 1, 2008

wannaBconnoisseur
The battles continue, really good stuff!!

Q-A few weeks ago, 2003 Les Cailloux, Chateauneuf du Pape, was great!
March 1, 2008

Philip
I’m really liking these head-to-heads. A very nice change of pace.
March 1, 2008

Greg
Gary, ANY win by the Knicks is stunning!
March 1, 2008

Philip
Well, I added my comment before waiting to hear the QoD. Two wines that did that to me recently (having a similar reaction) were:

* 2002 ChÃ¢teau de Flaugergues
* 1999 Louis Bernard Vacqueyras

Some of the greatness was the company I had for the sampling, but a lot of it were the wines as well. Yum!
March 1, 2008

Jim in Atlanta
I am a big fan of Anderson Valley pinot and have been buying from Navarro for many years. And the place is great to visit too. QOTD – I had two different Molly Dookers last night at a restuarant that exceeded my expectations. I am not a big fruit bomb lover, but these both were excellent, especially for the price.
March 1, 2008

SF Young
Love the show…..an informative and structured tasting format without the formalitities.
March 1, 2008

James
QOTD – That’s an easy one. A 2002 Kilikanoon Riesling from the Clare Valley. Mind blowing!
March 1, 2008

lincoln
2003 piramimma petite verdot from australia!! very cool juice!!
March 1, 2008

Blake
QOTD: While I don’t think I had quite your reaction, but for it’s price point, the Little Penguin Pinot is quite remarkable in my opinion.
March 1, 2008

Bingedrinker
QOTD: another pinot, mainly because I really didn’t expect to like it this much: 2001 Arcadian Gary’s Vineyard in May ‘06.
March 1, 2008

Armindo
QtÂª do mosteirÃ´ grande escolha 2000 Douro(portugal)great wine
March 1, 2008

agentorange
GV

Great show. Big ups to you!

We have been pimping the Anderson Valley to anyone who will listen (or not), and now we seem smart for a change…

QOTD: As we watched this episode we were sipping a 1997 chianti classico riserva that we snagged from a bargain bin for $5. Total fabulousness. Complete surprise.
March 1, 2008

Smith MBA
I don’t think I have ever had Gary’s reaction to anything, but I am a calm dude.
March 1, 2008

yowens
We’ve had that amisfield and really enjoyed it. QOTD: Huia savignon blanc
March 2, 2008

Tina Smith
Yes, Gary, Anderson Valley rocks! Always has-one of the better kept secrets in Cali. qotd-had the absolutely amazing Long Shadows 2004 Chester-Kidder Proprietary Red Blend from Walla Walla, Wa. Wanted to crawl into the bottle and live there!!
March 2, 2008

Brian Johnson
QOTD – 2004 Limited Release Pepper Tree Cabernet Sauvignon from Australia
March 2, 2008

Steve
QOTD: 20046 Breggo Anderson Valley Pinot Noir. After Gary’s discussion I got 1/2 a case and am loving it!
March 2, 2008

mikeyrad
Last night we went to a dinner party and brought the 2005 Chateau Les Secrets De Cardinale St Emilion that Gary recommended on a previous episode. Let me tell you, it was positively orgasmic and practically life-altering. Well, maybe I exaggerated a little about it changing my life, but I did order another half case as soon as I got home. It is absolutely incredible.
March 2, 2008

wayno da wino
Yo Gee !!
Thanx for exposin’ da Phillips Hill Pinot Noir!! Never had heard
of it till it hit da Thunder Show !

QOTD: Kinda went gaa-gaa over a Kistler-Kistler Vyd-Chardonnay 2004
i had da odher day!! Yuuuuuuuuum !!!!!!!
March 2, 2008

malliemcg
QTOD: Most recent wine that blew me away – Majella Cab Sauv (2001) [Coonawarra].
March 3, 2008

Andrew
Hi Gary

I’m like these head-to-haed match ups; an interesting and fun change.

QOTD: The last wine to probably knock me like that was Ca’del Bosco Franciacorta Brut, an absolute delight of a wine

Cheers
Andrew
March 3, 2008

MacNPhish
I just wanted to let everyone know I was able to find the 2005 Phillips Hill Toulouse Pinot Noir at a place called The Wine Shop in Healdsburg, CA. They only had 10 bottles, I bought 3 of them.

There number is (707) 433-0433.
March 3, 2008

pawncop
What a great episode.

QOTD I have yet to find a wine that has thrilled me as you have demonstrated. I have really begun to enjoy my wines more but will continue to learn.
March 3, 2008

Shawn
The last wine that made me go completely nuts (which is basically what you did), was the Mitolo Savitar Shiraz ‘05. I’ve never had a better shiraz, and I can almost still taste the aftertaste after two months. Brilliant.
March 3, 2008

Colin
GV – A little behind – but I’m glad I caught this show!
March 3, 2008

David Eldred
the best wine I have ever had… and am now buying as much as I can (which is not much due to finances lol) is a 2005 killer bee cabernet sauvignon. Killer bee is an exclusive to wine styles wine stores. I know I am new to the wine game, but this wine is honestly the best wine I have ever had so far.
March 3, 2008

Rob P
There are 2 wines that made me react that way recently…the Rosso di Altesino and the Avignonesi Vino Nobile di Montepulciano. I was very excited when I drank both of these.
March 4, 2008

Jayhitek
QOTD: Chateau Margaux
March 4, 2008

CORSkier
QOTD: New winery in Southern Oregon called Applegate Red, all three that I tasted (two bordeaux blends, one syrah based blend) were fantastic. Unirrigated, totally concentrated fruit. Bought a mixed case on the spot, blew me away.
March 4, 2008

DARREL LAS VEGAS
Good Bad a always react like that!
March 4, 2008

J-Pipes
QOTD: Oh god, I don’t KNOW……… I NEED that!!!!! I’m starved for wines like that!!!!!!!!!! Thanks for depressing the HECK out of me.
Oh, but I will let you know when I DO!
March 5, 2008

Paul Horan
QOTD: The 2006 Cinghiale Pinot Noir from Del Dotto Vineyards in Napa. Like $EX in a glass… A little pricey at $75 bones, but that’s how I roll.

-Paul in VA-
(had a fantastic day at the 2008 Napa Valley marathon too!)
March 6, 2008

Andrew
Toulouse is one of the most famous vineyards in the deep end of Anderson Valley. Look for other great wines from this site by MacPhail, Baxter, and Toulouse vineyards.
March 6, 2008

Mr.Ambassador
Loving the H2H competition!

The last wine that I went a bit crazy over was Zanzibar Winery’s “Sandra” red blend (Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, Syrah). The winery is located in Oregon (they use the Owen Roe facilities) and grapes are sourced from Horse Heaven Hills AVA in Washington. I also really love the Boudreaux reds from Walla Walla valley.
March 6, 2008

Tommy Vernieri
QOTD: I don’t think I’ve ever been that excited about a wine. Sounds good though, 100 cases seems crazy. I think the Jessup 2001 Cab. was the wine that I was most excited about it when I tasted it, but it was not really exciting at all when I had it with dinner rather than at the end of a day of tasting.
March 7, 2008

Andy
2000 Delas Freres Hermitage Marquis de Tourette. I was somehow even more amazed later when I learned that that is (in theory) at best halfway up the quality scale in the Northern Rhone. Wow.
March 9, 2008

Dan-o
I have to say that I 2 wines have done this to me recently.
1) Paul Hobbs Pinot Noir.
2) Chateau Quinault L’Enclos 2000 – like drinking chocolate covered berries.

One other wine that I had was from a friend of mine’s brother in law. He lives in CA and makes wine on the side. He made an awesome Syrah that really blew me away. I am looking to get a case of that wine.
March 11, 2008

Zinny
Gary – we ordered a few bottles of this based on your recommendation. We were not disappointed!

I don’t want to say too much or else it will become too hard to get this wine.
March 14, 2008

Lawrence Leichtman
Thanks for the tip. Just ordered 3 bottles from them and can’t wait to try it. The 1982 Leoville La Cases 1982 that was opened this weekend. What a killer wine.
April 3, 2008

Quinn
Go Canada (sorry perpetually catching up—Gary, you are a machine!). I really dig radishes, I would love to have tasted that Amisfield.
April 23, 2008

LuvsChandon
catching up, QOTD: Sequoia Grove Cabernet Reserve 04, awesome tasting it at the winery, then enjoyed last Christmas with Prime Rib, made A LOT of noise when I drank it!
June 17, 2008

AndrewG
Qotd: The last earth shaking wine I tried was an oregon pinot from a small producer called Matello. Their Whistling Ridge North single vineyard is down right amazing, and at 30 bones I feel a steal. Only 70 cases, and I don’t think they have a web presence as of yet, but WOW.
January 8, 2009

Dessert Wine Nerd
These battle royals are fun and I hope you do more of them in the future. Even though I probably cant find them cause this show is nearly a year old, its fun to see you point out the gems for us. At least someone will be enjoying them. QOTD: Cant remember. I havent been drinking that much wine lately ( at least ones that made me go WOW!) because Ive been buying ones to cellar. That ends now. Next time I go to my wine shop Im dropping 80 bones or so and getting like 6 wines to drink now.
September 21, 2009

ulu ulu ulu ulu
I haven’t thought about Quick in a long long time. I haven’t even had chocolate milk in years.

Gary – I think you should do a show regarding wine / cheese / food and well being. What is the difference between being happy and perhaps not as healthy as you could be, and being healthy and happy as a result of your healthiness.

QOTD: Hillside Select
October 20, 2009

richardvinifera
QOTD: Marques De La Concordia 2005 Rioja Reserva, perfect new world fruit, but classic rioja flavour, explosive aroma, great grip and finish, it was £6 (probably retail for $9 in US?)