A Smorgasbord Wine Tasting

A Smorgasbord Wine Tasting – Episode #677

May 15, 2009

Gary Vaynerchuk tastes 4 wines that have nothing to do with each other.

Having trouble viewing this video? Try the Quicktime version.

Comments on this episode(197) Leave a comment ›

“Gary,

Thanks for showing a new side of Pinotage (vs. the usual nega…” by Michael Elkin
“hi gary, i think it is good how you keep retail separate from show con…” by chukhead-ted
View all 197 ›

Wines tasted in this episode:

2006 Dr. Frank Konstantin Pinot GrisNew York Other White
2006 Antinori Bolgheri VermentinoOther Tuscan White Wine
2007 Shoofly Chook Raffle ChardonnayAustralian Chardonnay
2006 Kanonkop PinotageSouth African Pinotage

Links mentioned in today’s episode.

The “Crush It!” announcement page

197 Responses

May 15, 2009

Redmeat
no comments yet…really?
May 15, 2009

Redmeat
wow first time first?!?
May 15, 2009

Jeff S.
Here I am commenting before I see the show!

I’ll get back to you on the Question of the Day.
May 15, 2009

John Farrin
4
May 15, 2009

jason
top five…. go friday
May 15, 2009

Redmeat
QOTD……doesn’t matter to me…you can’t ship to Washington….and that makes me sad because many of the wines you review are not available here in the Seattle area…
May 15, 2009

Jeff S.
Gary!

I asked Randy Jackson what he thought about you offering special deals on WLTV. He told me to tell you that much like your singing, “It’s a little bit pitchy, dawg”.
May 15, 2009

Dr.Scott
qotd – sure, why not? If you are concerned about being gimmicky you could limit the offer to special occasions or times. Like the faster pacing, but longer shows give more detail. The show has an ebb and flow in pacing, which is really nice.
May 15, 2009

WineWoman
The action figures are back. Nice candy-striper shirt. I was wondering about that Shoofly Chook Chard. Thanks for having it on the show.

QOTD: A few special offers and codes are always appreciated for the Vaynernation.
May 15, 2009

NY Pete
where’s the couch GV?
May 15, 2009

NY Pete
nice couch, you should utilize it.
May 15, 2009

NY Pete
when are you in the zone?
May 15, 2009

sharon
Hmmmm Pinotage. Me, too.
qotd: No
May 15, 2009

NY Pete
pitchy pitch … ha ha
May 15, 2009

gotsha
QOTD….I’m peaVed that WL still cannot ship to Illinois, so my answer is NO. If I can’t enjoy a discount on WL shipping, nobody else should. Why can’t WL figure out a way to ship to the most corrupt state in the Union? If the US Senate seat can be bought for only $1 million, how cheap would it be to get a shipping law changed?
May 15, 2009

Dr T in NC
QOTD — nope . . . well, save the free shipping for the mystery packs or other group tastings
May 15, 2009

David T (@ONUMello)
Nice episode. I did like the format- just throw it all out there! Your enthusiasm has been picking up lately, but it’s such an exciting time in your life! New book + new baby = awesome.

I just tried a cabernet-pinotage blend yesterday that was also quite good; a bing cherry explosion.

QOTD: I agree it would likely interfere too much. Part of your pride in the early episodes was your refute to ‘you’re just trying to promote WL’s wines’ by saying ‘no, we’re giving some terrible scores & some of my longtime clients are pissed at me’. That being said, I still think it would be a good tribute to the Vayniacs, so it could maybe work it you added an extra degree of separation. For example, don’t directly announce it on the show while you’re rating wines, but you could give a wink-wink nudge-nudge to head over to the WLTV Facebook page and post something there
May 15, 2009

Leif erik Sundstrom
Haven’t had Dr. Frank’s PG but have tasted the Riesling and was quite impressed. In fact at a Riesling symposium last Dec. I saw him on a panel and we tasted it then, and immediately after both Johannes Selbach (Selbach-Oster, Mosel) and Armin Diel (Diel, Nahe) both took time out to comment on how impressed they were with the wine. Big ups, no doubt. Armin doesn’t say ANYTHING unless he means it, especially when it comes to compliments. So the Riesling IS worth trying.

QOTD:: Ummm, maybe my memory is faulty, but don’t you OFTEN offer up free shipping codes???
May 15, 2009

Kim G
I think you missed one thing about the Pinotage. You were drinking a very young 2006. On the back label, it will tell you that it has years before it gets to the heights of maturity, and boy, can I tell you it is true! I just had a 1995 Kanonkop Pinotage last Saturday which was stunning. Of course you sell young wines, but one of the joys of wine is to drink the mature ones and to keep a number in the cellar (or under the bed for that matter) just to see them evolve!

I enjoy the diversity of the shows, so just keep up the good work!
May 15, 2009

David T (@ONUMello)
Weird, when you click to view comments, the oldest are at the top for this episode.
May 15, 2009

Tooch
Wanted to propose a toast to my friend Chris – he unexpectedly passed away last week and he was a true wine lover. A absolute shame.
May 15, 2009

guymandude
I’m huge fan of Pinotage .Thanks for the show and all the effort.
QOTD;It may be tough because you can’t ship wine everywhere.
But, you could offer it on schwag or stuff. Especially if you leave comments,that gets lurkers.
May 15, 2009

Laurie in VT
QOTD: I’m with Dr. T – no except for maybe the secret packs. Speaking of which, it’s been awhile: maybe you should do a welcome to the world Vayner-baby secret pack (and pre-tape so we can be enjoying it while you’re learning about the 12-diaper-a-day routine!)

I liked the pace of today’s show, though mixing it up works well, too.
May 15, 2009

urbwes
qotd: keep -em seperate. You are smart to remove all doubt about your priorities.
May 15, 2009

Scott EJ
Thanks, G. This show brought me back to some of your older ones (circa 06/07) when it was just you and some wine. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy your guests, too. I guess I’m more into the content with less distractions.

Also, congrats to AJ, your new venture, and your book.

QOTD. I say leave it as it is. If someone wants something from WLTV, they can find it. I won’t mention anything ’cause I’m a selfish prick and find it hard to get some wines from WL due to the mad rush generated by your score/reaction.
May 15, 2009

Mr Cook
I live in the Finger Lakes region so I am very familure with Dr. Frank’s and really like the 07 dry riesling. Sadly, their tasting building burned to the ground about a month ago. The rest of the winery was ok.

QOTD: Free shipping? Of course, but I would keep it to special occasions.
May 15, 2009

Jacob L.
Glad to see you back in the thunder chair. I like the trips and guests as a change of pace, but its always nice to get back to business as it were. Glad that you had two good wines this episode, I felt so bad for you when you made the faces for those crappy wines last episode (didn’t stop me from laughing though).

QOTD: Being in Ohio, I couldn’t take advantage even if I wanted to, but I think doing rewards for watching would be a slippery slope, and it would become less about the experience of expanding palates, and make the show more about the deals.
May 15, 2009

amgryger
QOTD: I think its probably better to keep a little distance between WLTV and the business. Besides, I already receive a multitude of offers from WL everyday.
May 15, 2009

castello
Until we can share the love with the states that can’t import wine you should keep it to a minimum. How about a campaign for changing the wine (world) laws?
Good show. Will have to look for the Pinotage.
May 15, 2009

Kevin
QOTD: live in Canada, so the info/opportunities would be irrelevant.

Good ep.
May 15, 2009

A.B
@gotsha , they ship to IL now.
QOTD: Don’t put it in the show, maybe post free shipping on twitter and do it one or twice a month or so. WLTV or WL is like a local coffee shop to me: great staff, friendly environment, and frank recommendations. Of course I can go to a Starbucks-i.e. a local wine shop- but I wouldn’t get that great experience. I would like to contribute to WLTV by buying wine from WL, but the shipping is killing me, especially if you are a poor college student as myself. But it’s up to you.

Ex-Lurker, first time poster
May 15, 2009

KAHUNA
QOTD: are you f-ing kidding me- there are 8 million free shipping codes all the time- every other wineliberary email has a free shipping code-Screw free shipping codes- I want free cheese!
May 15, 2009

Robin C
I was just looking up that exact same vermentino because a friend and I were going to an Italian restaurant in Charleston – Spoleto Festival – this coming weekend and that looked like their best bet by the glass, but it turned out they aren’t open on Sunday, so instead we’re going to a restaurant that has a 3 floor wine wall so we’re bound to find something there.
QOTD: pitchy, but you could direct watchers to a link.
May 15, 2009

Dylan
So Gary, I just watched your Web 2.0 keynote. And I just want you to know, that even though what you do sucks…I appreciate it. Thanks for pumping out great stuff.
May 15, 2009

Kittysafe
qotd: Gary you have to understand many of us viewers do purchase from Wine Library, so I see nothing wrong for a way of thanks to give us some good deals, whether you show it in free shipping codes, or more wines with the WOTM club, any savings you give to the viewers can’t be a bad thing ever.

It’s only pitchy to the people who aren’t buying, but to us who are loyal to the library, we appreciate the savings.
May 15, 2009

Kittysafe
Not sure about the pace of today’s show, you came off as really bipolar lol.
May 15, 2009

Michael Schoonmaker
QOTD: Check out @wldaily.

I like the “digestability” of the speed + laid-back-ness combo. Awesome.
May 15, 2009

looper
Gotta try Pinotage. Every time that you try one on the show, you seem so intrigued by it.
QOTD: Other retailers have done a 1 cent shipping for certain months. Nice touch. A little more relevant to my purchasing than the Cinderella play.
May 15, 2009

LisaPeacea
Contact hyper buzz after watching that! lol Im wide awake now!!
May 16, 2009

DasNOOB
QOTD: Infomercial in the making?
May 16, 2009

manonthemoon
Pinotage, I just threw up a little in my mouth….

QOTD: Its up to you man, gotta say there seems to always be free shipping codes lying around the site one way or the other.
May 16, 2009

Marc-China Wine Tours
Geez GV, don’t be afraid to promote yourself! hahaha…as if you didn’t know
Heck, if we have to endure all these videos, we should at least get a coupon!!

QOTD: First had pinotage in Franschoek, South Africa and loved it!
May 16, 2009

Jay
QOTD: Keep ‘em separate. If he wants a free shipping code, he should follow santagaryvee on Twitter or join the Facebook fan page. just imho.
May 16, 2009

Thomas W
QOTD: Since I’m in TN where shipping wine is currently not happening, I’m neutral regarding whether it would selfishly benefit me or not. That being said, it could be a cool idea to once in a while have a free shipping code on your chalkboard. You wouldn’t even have to mention it. That way you’re not being overly pitchy. The observant viewers would pick up on it. But keeping it to a minimum would be good. We don’t want to lose the focus on the wine knowledge.
May 16, 2009

Zach
Don’t care about shipping codes- we live on the west coast. Like the pace- keep it movin’!
Great episode.
May 16, 2009

Megan
QOTD: Yes, I would love to see a special promotion for Wine Library TV viewers — I don’t think it would be too smarmy or overt; rather, I’d think of it as a reward for loyal fans who watch the episodes the whole way through. (Not like that’s a burden — didn’t mean to imply that!)

Keep the enthusiasm coming Gary… That’s why we keep watching!
May 16, 2009

Shannon Ehlers
Hey Gary,
I liked the contrast between the different wine styles in this episode.

QOTD: I would love a discount code or an “easter egg” of some sort to use in the store, and if you included one in every episode, I’d think that was just fine.

By the way, I would love to see an episode that contrasts the various wine making regions of the United States, both established (Napa, Finger Lakes, Texas) and evolving/returning regions (midwest, etc).

Oh, and I’m anxiously awaiting the Omaha episode. Please tell me you were able to save it!

-Shannon
@littletownblues
May 16, 2009

Keith Miller
Ineresting…..
May 16, 2009

Keith Miller
Should have said….

Interesting…makes me go hmmmmmm
May 16, 2009

howlr5
Keep crushing it Vaynerchuk.
May 16, 2009

BigPieps
First comment!

Loved the pace…but that doesn’t necessarily mean it would be preferred for all episodes.

The QOTD is what prompted me to comment:

In my opinion, when you keep the store out of WLTV, you keep in the integrity of the show. As a reviewer of wine, making recommendations, etc. what are you without your integrity? I think you of all people would never want others to feel as if you weren’t being honest or had lost the integrity of the show.

Great shows! Keep ‘em coming!
May 16, 2009

TimBoDo
QOTD – Plenty of free shipping codes in the WL emails. As much as I appreciate free shipping, it might suggest an aire of slimy-ness to people that don’t know better. If you want to do more free shipping on the site or via email, however… hell yeah. But pazzzzz on the idea for the show.

Good pace – nice to have a “normal” show again.
May 16, 2009

liangtfm
Good show today Gary, went straight through the wines without interruptions or going off track (although I personally like those moments) but really interesting and I can’t wait to try a Pinotage.

QOTD – It would be interesting to play around with a free shipping offer in your show once in a while. I don’t know about other Vayniacs but I do like to order from WL as the prices are great and if it’s free shipping it’s def. worth it.
May 16, 2009

Damaged Fox
I liked the pace. Knocked out those 4 in no time.
As much as I like to see you get out,
it’s nice to see you back to your table.
May 16, 2009

TommyB
Good show Gary but maybe a little too “pacy for my palate” initially. If time allows I think you could slow it down a little and contemplate the wines further etc. Call me a traditionalist but wine is a contemplative thing which should never be rushed! But you actually did that on the Pinotage which is interesting as that was the one that struck you the most…
May 16, 2009

TommyB
QOTD: I wouldn’t bother with any promotions/ offers etc Gary, the secret pack thing works well but it should be left at that in my opinion. There are thousands of people who watch this show who don’t live anywhere near America (including myself). They watch to learn about wine/ be entertained/ are fans etc etc, not to try to get discounts. As you said I think it would seem a bit salesy. But on that point – shipping abroad???… I suppose that would be too difficult thinking about it.. it would be nice to be able to order wine from your website instead of just having to look at it!
May 16, 2009

lurker'09
QOTD:
Trust your instincts!
You make a strong first impression.
Too much self promotion could hurt your credibility with the uninitiated.
After a few hundred episodes one realizes that you are a wealth of information.
You are spreading a message that should be heard, (even if you are screaming it.)
May 16, 2009

IASHERMAN
Hey Gary:

I think it is a good idea to throw some of the free shipping codes on the wine library tv show. It really could not hurt and shipping can be quite expensive. I enjoy the show when you have contests, secret packs, Schwag packs and other giveaways. It truly sets wine library tv a step above all others.

-IA
May 16, 2009

Richie
QOTD: I think you should leave it the way it is. That way it doesn’t have the aspect of you wanting to make money or something with WLTV.
May 16, 2009

Bruce Sorrell
Hey Gary,

Tell Mr. Mot he needs more hours in the garden. He told you the plant with a blossom like a cat’s face was an Iris. Error. It’s a pansy. Photo sample at:
http://www.zazzle.co.uk/purple_pansies_print-228732467435707017

Please let him know he owes me a bottle of Bragato Tocai Friulano for this expert gardening advice.

Great show, as always! Keep it up.

Slainte!

Bruce
May 16, 2009

ex-lurkdawg
I liked this episode as usual. I like pinotage, too, but a few people I know really knock it. I guess they just don’t like the flavor profile. I don’t think you should link WL offers with the show, although you could keep offering free shipping via other outlets as you have been all along. And now I must mention it again … how about a Madeira episode with a vintage Madeira at the end? It’s been a LONG time since I started asking.
May 16, 2009

tcatjo
I understand staying informative rather than using WLTV as a selling tool but let’s be honest, it will be a selling tool for someone-as we look for the wines you have on the show. For me, the wines are hard to find and free shipping would give me a little help in maybe buying something I’m dying to try (and I want to try EVERYTHING). Would love to have that option sometimes but love the show and nothing will keep me from watching even if I can’t find the wines.
May 16, 2009

Howard
Enjoyed the episode. I live in Maryland and we can’t have wines shipped to us. Maryland’s wine shipping laws does not CRUSH IT!!
May 16, 2009

DF
Great, old-school feel show today. It was all about the wine, there was good and not-so-good, a lot of old-school Gary flavor combos (plum, banana, bacon bits– classic). Just a lot of fun all around.

One commenter said you came off as bipolar– maybe what he/she meant was manic. It doesn’t matter. That’s the secret of your success, the energy. Stay with that.

QOTD: We cannot ship wine to NC, but maybe my friend Sean (@fullsteam) can change that. Props to him for what he’s already done for beer. If you already have free shipping codes in emails and other places, I think that’s where they should stay. You have 15 minutes or so every day to do wine. Let that be the main thing.
May 16, 2009

MaRc
if you’re asking about pace of the show…i feel you’re a little abrupt in the way you talk and act today.Not really the best to my enjoyment considering past episodes…

QOTD: I don’t live in the states, so it won’t really affect me, would it? Anyway, I think it’s fine when you give out freebies or drop lil comments about what you’re doing, but maybe not so much on your business, however, tasting wines that you have onsale wouldn’t really be a big problem!
May 16, 2009

KevO
Gar, I really liked the old pace of the segment. Watching for a half an hour + is tough. Keep up the pace and go blind tasting more often – test your skills for us, that’s what I’m sayin…

QOTD: Nothing wrong with spiffs for the viewers, especially if you are referencing the wines reviewed for that day, would give a spontaneous purchase incentive. Afterall, why do you do WineLibraryTV anyway? Let’s not kid ourselves.
May 16, 2009

Leslie
Dr Frank’s best white is Rkasiteli. AGREE on Italian whites, most interesting of all whites, Spanish whites next. Shoofly wines are all just ehh. Pinotage has such a range from gritty & stinky too what you described in the Kanonkop. I like this kind of show- right down to business!
May 16, 2009

California Cab Lover
I get winelibrary emails anyway, so it doesn’t matter to me if you say something on the show or not. I think you are receptive enough to your fan base that if you got a lot of negative feedback on the promo stuff, you would drop it.
Free shipping is crucial in my decision to buy online. If shipping is high, then the good deal on the bottle is not such a good deal.
May 16, 2009

Chris Lotz
Good show! I like the hippy hi five/toke, the pace of the show was rockin and rollin. I have never bought anything from WL, but if you gave me an incentive, i definitely would
May 16, 2009

David Dadekian
QOTD: I agree it’s a fine line. However, in all honesty, you own a retail store and the links to the wine (mostly) go to that retail store. So there’s no way to completely divorce yourself from that. Hey, it’s synergy!
May 16, 2009

Don
I love bacon!!! Keep crushing it Gary. I need to try a Pinotage.

QOTD: It is a fine line and I’m interested to hear you talk more about the pros and cons on the show. Agreed that you need to try to maintain an appearance of objectivity, and that would be even more difficult throwing out free shipping codes on the air. Seems to me like most of your viewers get the Wine Library emails anyways that sometimes have free shipping. One idea is that you could periodically suggest people to sign up for the emails but not actually give out free shipping codes on the show. Ehhh??
May 16, 2009

Ivan
QOTD: I thnk there is something just plain good about gifting the peeps who are loyal viewers with something extra now and then… free shipping on anything in stock is great. other ideas BOGO. invite to special event etc.

Watchout: Might need to have a cap since once word spreads everyone will look to get the gift.
May 16, 2009

Chris Bartow
The retail store is already integrated into the site when you do the secret pack. I don’t see how giving out coupon codes is any different.

Would rather see freebies for the WLTV viewers. Use this coupon code and get a free wrist band with any order.
May 16, 2009

Zac Weiss
Great show, great wines, it’s been a while since you seemed to find wines that really made your nose give some crazy ideas to your brain. You seemed in a funny mood today; baby coming + aj graduation making you reflect?

QOTD: won’t really affect me since I’m in France, but I’ll say you should let’er rip if you feel like it. Make your offers a little personalized. If somehow you could get your ‘coupon’ to only work for certain varietals or regions or whatever, get people to try new things. You could make a learning experience out of it rather than just being ‘pitchy.’ Which would be fine as well in my opinion…
May 16, 2009

Terrance Young
The flower with a cat face is a pansy, I think.

The speedy yet sweet ep is good but so are the slower paced one. However you bring it is good to me, just as long as you bring it, GV.

I live in Japan so I don’t think I can order anything from Winelibrary so I’m not so interested in seeing you tie things to your show closer to the products sold at WL. Plus, the integrity thing does come into question even though I feel personally certain you will always keep it real. No reason to give the haters something to latch onto.
May 16, 2009

Dawn S
Really like the faster pace; the more wines reviewed the better!
May 16, 2009

Jungsenson
Pace is perfect Gary and I agree with you, keep WLTV separate from your business.

I would like to see more italian white wines (and not the buk standard Pinot Grigio)on your line up. One of my current favorites are the falaghina wines.
But there are som many grapes and wines in Italy that really need some more attention (why not a white chiavenasca from Valtellina…)

Great Show, many thanks from a rainy London
Jungsenson
May 16, 2009

DAve A
QOTD: yes. make us special. ghez… but not every day. see? oui? We are special, ugh? a little? or just fodder to your ego? hahahahaha. Kidding!

I’d like to know I got a special deal from watching this. Good show. Pinotage, sounds interesting.
May 16, 2009

JOEYdaMUSH
gary, thanks for going back to your roots
May 16, 2009

Josh Klein
I just returned from a driving trip through New Mexico & Colorado and to pass the time I watched about 15 or so back episodes of WLTV. Thank God for iPods and WLTV podcasts to help get me through the desert.

QOTD – I could go either way with the offers. I know that WLTV is an extension of The Wine Library, so it really doesn’t bother me that you would cross promote with a little something-something every now an then.
May 16, 2009

M
QOTD: It’s your show! Plug or don’t plug, you always Crush It.

Shipping codes don’t help us in PA.

I like the fast pace. It helped me catch up. I was a few shows behind.
May 16, 2009

Beeper
QOTD: I don’t think you should worry about marketing the Wine Library…if you could ship to South Dakota, I would love the opportunity get free shipping once in a while or something like that.
May 16, 2009

Jessica Sutherland
Congrats to your little brother, Gary, from another BU alum!!
May 16, 2009

Hans
Great show Gary.

QOTD: I think that a free shipping/discount code every couple months would not make the show “pitchey”at all. It would definitely encourage me to try more wine and expand my palate as shipping costs are the main bottleneck for me.
May 16, 2009

ben from boston
thanks for comment, made my day.

qotd- go with your instincts, keep the education and the commerce seperate. there are already plenty of good reasons to watch.
great pace, good execution.
May 16, 2009

Jason S.
QOTD: I agree that it does seem to cross the line with the retail side of the store, but don’t the links for each of the wines reviewed do that too – they link straight to the retail side? I think you should give show some love to the WLTV viewers and provide some specials – maybe on some of the wines you review highly so we can try them a little more easily.
May 16, 2009

Cameron J
QOTD – I don’t think offering an occasional free shipping would be that big a deal. It might help some people try a few more wines. I’m sure some might object and say it taints your reviewing independence, but I don’t think most of the Vaynernation would agree.

Congratulations to AJ.
May 16, 2009

Stuart
QOTD – I never like to be sold – so I’m glad you don’t do offers or deals for WLTV viewers. I liked the shows pace today.
May 16, 2009

mikek
Gary, Like the brisk pace,(you can chill on laid back Friday’s)LOL!

QOTD: Gary, THE reason you are successful is “you care”! (YOU just said it on CNN)! You are REAL! You bring passion & quality content; but more importantly INTEGRITY which is why I give a damn about what you have to say…AT ALL! If this wasn’t true, I’d buy a copy of Wine Spectator! haha

You have a WLTV web-site, WLTV daily offerings, facebook, twitter, midnite cinderella specials…Keep the retail, the “biz”, the free shipping and specials THERE. If people have been following you for more than 2 episodes…they know where to go for the “deals”. I respect this site for what it is NOT, a dumping ground for your inventory! You CRUSH IT by staying true to YOU and by doing so … staying true to US!

Thanks for all the effort. You have my continuing support. (and I drive 30 miles, every 4 weeks to pick-up my orders; and I live less than 1/2 mile away from 2 major wine stores, Gary’s Wines & Bottle King)! I love ya, with my heart AND my wallet! Stay TRUE man, keep it real!
May 16, 2009

Mad Hatter
QOTD: YES! YES! YES! As a proud member of the CKC, I would absolutely love a free shipping code every few months. Don’t worry about being too “commercial” , wine library is a great place and everyone who has watched even a few episodes of WLTV know that you are honest and upfront with us the viewers.
May 16, 2009

Harry
Nice show, I liked the pace for a 4 bottle review. Keeping it tight and under 20 minutes is nice. Balanced out with the more in depth single bottle episodes, and I’m happy.
I hear you on the conflict of interest, although you are very transparent about everything. Anyone who watches you knows your honest intentions, like today when you trashed a big seller in the store, so I wouldn’t worry too much about it. I don’t see any problem with a free shipping or bonus once in a while.
May 16, 2009

Steeler Nation
QOTD: Every once and a while it would be nice to throw the Wine Library TV crew a bone. Living in the communist state of PA where shipping wine into the state is not allowed, I would rather have a % off the normal price rather than free shipping, but that’s just me.

I like this tight four wine tasting format the best but it’s also nice to keep miving it up though.

Question for you Gary. Why do you hate the Steelers so much? They are a tuff blue collar team run by a classy family. I actually would think if Russia had a football team it would be just like the Steelers:-)

great show!
May 16, 2009

Sean
WOW…YOU SWALLOWED!!!! (Don’t think I have seen that EVER!)

Good pacing…kept things moving nicely.

QOTD: I would LOVE some shipping discounts. However, no matter how liberal New England is, its illegal to get wine shipped to me in Rhode Island OR Massachusetts. DAMN PURITAN LAWS!!!!! Guess we will have to stop by the shop the next time we drive down to visit my parents in Pennsylvania.
May 16, 2009

sam
Pretty in pink!

A lot of NRG there Gary! It’s nice to see…

Congrats to your bro AJ!

Good luck with the book and your future projects!

Ciao!
May 16, 2009

John
The flower that looks like a cat or more specifically has “cat whiskers” is the Pansy and not the Iris.
May 16, 2009

Keith Brown
QOTD: I say NO Gary. You’ve often said (publicly) you don’t do the show to drive business to WL and I think you need to stick to that. That has earned you cred to this point and I think you’d lose more in the long run by making offers to viewers. I am a WL customer, and I get plenty of free shipping offers through the mailing list. You’ve promoted your books on WLTV with free shipping codes which I took advantage of, but I see that as more geared to selling books than wine. I’m sure you’re looking at it as more of a “gift” to viewers, not as a sales tactic, but still, your audience is savvy enough that they will shop WL if they feel like it and see your prices “are insane” or that you have stuff they can’t get elsewhere, and they will be on the mailing list and wait for those free shipping offers they can’t resist. No need to pander…
May 16, 2009

mrpat56
QOTD— I would like free shipping, BUT,, I would prefer you not offer it on WLTV. I think you have a lot of credibiliy the way things are now. You need to keep the wine library retail sector seperate from WLTV. I have seen you dis wines that you say you sell a lot of, and I applauded you for that. If you start making “special” deals here, then you are corrupting the objectivity that is needed for accurate tastings. Give more free shipping at the retail web site and send them here, but don’t offer the deal here to send them to your store. We all go there anyway. Keep this site non-commercial and without conflicts of interest. We know you make your money selling wine, you sell enough to stay honest here and continue to continue to look that way, Thanks for your objectivity– keep it here, keep the deals on the wine library site.
May 16, 2009

Jeremy Kath
Gary,

Why not mention a shipping code? You’ve already tied WLTV to WineLibrary with links at the bottom for all the wines you review on the show that are also sold in the store, so if you feel like it would help your business, I don’t care because I already know you’ve got the retail side of things going. I’m not sure it’s preferable for a wine critic to do this, but I’m cool with it because I know where you’re coming from and I can decide for myself after watching your reviews. AND, more importantly, this is key, you’re not afraid to pan wines that you sell in the store…like the Shoo Fly you just rocked with an 81. God bless. Jeremy
May 16, 2009

Bobbie Smith
QOTD: Unnecessary. I like the clean editorial. People can sign up for your mailing list to get shipping codes.

Especially liked the Pinotage commentary. I have not experienced enough of it and needed a reminder. Love to be continually expanding my palate.

On another note, my son calls you Chucky Vayner and thinks my husband and I should spit more while we drink wine. It just cracks me up and adds a couple good laughs at dinnertime.
May 16, 2009

F Jackie Martling
qotd: In this economy every saved buck helps. I say Yes!
May 16, 2009

Eric Holm
As a long time lurker need to KISS(keep it simple stupid). The can go to the shop on line site and get all of it!!!!!!!!!!!!
May 16, 2009

John
Hey Gary, loved the show today. Back to old format. And the pace is great.

Also, I’m emailing you a great song: Jonathan Richman’s “He Gave Us the Wine to Taste It”. Check it out!

Thanks,
John
Echo Park
May 16, 2009

John
Hi Gary, I figured I would just post it for you.

Here’s Jonthan Richman’s “He Gave Us the Wine to Taste It”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUr5tI7Hiqc

John
Echo Park
May 16, 2009

Jamie Draper
I say no, keep the show and your retail effort very separate. Impartiality keeps you unique. I give you business even from from the west coast because of this.
May 16, 2009

benbron
awesome awesome show gary – the grab bag episodes are always a favorite, especially when the wines are obscure like the vermentino, each individual wine was a learning experience.
qotd – No, unless you do a blind tasting and then your favorite goes on sale. otherwise it will make me distrust your partisanship towards the wine in your rating
May 16, 2009

Christopher Scoggin
I like the themed shows but this was an fun random selection of wines. I will have to see if I can dig up the Dr. Frank.

QOTD: Who wants to turn down a discount or something free? At the same time I can see your concern about bringing the link between your commercial business and this enterprise. I think if it is done rarely enough then it would not be a problem.
May 16, 2009

RickyB
Hey Gary!

Big time lurker coming out. First comment for the thunder show!

Been watching since about 100 episodes ago, love the show but it’s a little hard for me to get into wine since I’m only 19. I live in PA so once I’m 21 I’ll take a ride over to jersey and check out the library!

Great episode, way to bring the thunder, love the variety! Good luck to you and your brother on starting your company! Much Love

Ricky
May 16, 2009

Peter_beckwith
Nothing like a fun show with random wines. I’m calling for another blind tasting, always fun. I think Ian has to step his game up and stump you one of these days. Don’t know if that is possible.

I also want to take the time to call out vay-ner-nation out there. There hasn’t been 200 comments in some time, common. I know people watch the show. Gary needs the feedback. I have an idea, have a taste off between Mott and Matt, who can guess closest to the score and price point. I’m sure you can find some that wine spectator has and brown bag them. Nothing like a good old competition. You be the ref.
May 17, 2009

Lawrence leichtman
Wow, GV on speed. I don’t think you should mix the video play with the commerce more than you already do. Free shipping is always nice but putting into WLTV would be a bit weird to me. By the way, I keep trying Pinotage but still don’t like it.
May 17, 2009

gomestar
Gary – Loved the pace of this episodes and I especially liked your enthusiasm. I’m excited to try that Vermentino, I had a wonderful glass at Mia Dona (near Bloomies) not long ago and I look forward to tasting more Italian whites.

QOTD: I wouldn’t mind a free shipping code every few months. While I agree that it’s good to keep business and the show separate, people also need to think about the business you might have lost by coming down hard on a popular, rare, or high-margin wine without shame or fear of retaliation. Whatever you do, just be 100% honest in your evaluations, that means more to me than any amount of free shipping codes.
May 17, 2009

Kittysafe
What’s with trying to keep the business and show seprate? They’re not seperate. Viewers do in fact buy from Wine Library, so how are they seperate?
May 17, 2009

thunderball (dave)
Great episode. Glad you like the Kanonkop…I can get it for about 17 bucks here at Costco (Japan)!! Awesome deal, gotta stock up.
May 17, 2009

Rich Ritter in NY
Well, we’re getting closer to the couch anyway. Pinotage is climbing my likeablility list. Everytime I try it I like it a little bit more.

QOTD: Don’t cross that line Gary.
May 17, 2009

Weston
qotd: Free shipping to Canada Ill take that!
May 17, 2009

Andrew W.
Gary V. huge fan of the show, some what of a lurker when it comes to comments. Was hoping you could throw out some birthday love to me on monday’s episode since my birthday is today Sun. 5/17/2009. Celebrating 22 yearz. To make the weekend even better, I graduated college on Saturday from Frostburg State University out in Western MD.
Thanks for the amazing work you do with WLTV.
May 17, 2009

jwink
Yes it’s a little “pitchy” and we know you want to sell wine; but it would be appreciated by the loyal viewers of the show. I think if you offered something with full disclosure, it will come off as less pitchy.

Like the pace 4 wines in 13 minutes [after subtracting the pre tasting intro] may be a 2009 record
May 17, 2009

Chopps
Hey man, small request…
Can you pronounce ‘chook’ properly, it’s rhymes with book or look or nook.
Cheers

QOTD: Don’t care either way, as long as it’s quick and doesn’t take up a lot of wine tasting time.
May 17, 2009

Tom
GV – QOTD Keep the retail out of the show.

I agree with you on the pinotage. Never tried one until I saw an early episode of WLTV. Now I love it.
May 17, 2009

jason
i lke the mixed bag shows from time to time. it is like some friends come over with all different stuff except i dont drink them.
qotd – you know what gary do what you want. im sure 98% will say give us free shipping from time to time, but we are just the consumers that maybe buy wine from you. i have only bought from you once or twice. just have free shipping when i have cash. + it it is not like you are giving free shipping to the wines you have on the show! maybe free shipping on everything but show wines????
have a good time at graduation this weekend
May 17, 2009

Doug
QOTD: Maybe you just need a dedicated “commerce” show. After all, you present a great variety of good wines, only SOME of which turn up in my local shops. So why not give your customers the opportunity to obtain hard-to-find wine a an affordable price point. If the show is labeled as “commerce”, people can skip it entirely…

In addition, why not have a regular segment entitled “What’s in Your Cellar?” where people come in with whatever wine they have around the house..Now that’s true web 2.0..
May 17, 2009

Adam J
Nice pace and energy this show…I really liked it, and mott kills it with the zooms.
QOTD: I agree with others that keeping WLTV free of promotions, etc…is probably a good idea. While it would not offend me at all, I can imagine it could turn off some people. The Wine Library Daily service is always there to hook us up with good deals. Thanks for the show!
May 17, 2009

eagleputt
Please… NO pitches on the show. Link them down below or write a comment yourself offering a deal. If you pan the wines on a show, you are not going to offer a deal. If you like the wines and offer a deal, you are setting yourself up for criticism – such as, “Gary has a butt load of wine to sell and a loyal following – all he has to do is says 90+ and it will fly off the shelves…” I, for one, don’t need another infomercial – next we’ll have flashing lights and buzzers going off. KEEP IT REAL…
May 17, 2009

RichE
QOTD #2
Loved the fast pace and more wines the merrier.

QOTD#1
You should offer free shipping.
It’s another way of helping people expand their PAL.
Perhaps when you do a taping on just 1 or 2 wine varietals and you encourage Vaniacs to go out and try one. That would be a good time to offer free shipping of any wine you carry, or perhaps can get, but limited to the varietal grape from the specific show.
Therefore you are being VERY TRUR to your message and additionally helping people in these difficult times to experience and expand their PAL,

If you had offered free shipping on a Pinotage today I would have ordered 1 or more.

Riche
Upstate, NY
May 17, 2009

paryb
Gary I understand the folks who don’t want the show to become pitchmen or something…but a couple thougths on that, this long into the show, I for one trust you…I am convinced that you are after sharing knowledge first and foremost on WLTV, and that if you started giving overstock wines 90+ just to sell them, the vaynernation are full of strong enough palletes that we’d call ya out anyway! I remember a ways back you had a little Ustream talk on a little wine(I think it was 40-50% Petite Verdot, I wish I membered the name), just because you thought it was so awesome…I really really dug that. I also love free shipping codes, if you offered one every once in a while it wouldn’t make me think “Gary wants to sell some wine” it would make me think “Wow Gary really wants us to try this wine” I mean you say, “go out and find this!” all the time, but if you threw in soemthing like that I’d think, Ok this warrants more attention.

Sorry for the Tolstoy!
May 17, 2009

Mike Berg
Gary- Your integrity is your most valuable asset. That said, it’s been a while since you did a 3 pack or 4 pack tasting. If you did those every 3 months or so and gave a deal on shipping- I think it would maintain your independence and expand pallets around the country. I live in Guam, 7942 miles away, but if I was in the States (and when I return), I would (will) totally be into it.

Cheers,
Mike
May 17, 2009

BlueFrank
Nice pace. Keeping the criticism and the sales distinct, underlines an integrity, that once crossed may be hard to re-achieve. U have an agressive email sales effort already. The NJ store is a joy to visit with an impressive wine collection and staff. The percieved independance of the TV program adds weight to your comments. Thanks for asking.
May 17, 2009

Matteo Fagin
I’m a huge fan of Vermentino from Sardenia and have not had any from other regions of Italy. Gary, would you say this Antinori wine has less minerality or more than Vermentino from Sardenia. How would you compare it in general to Vermentino di Gallura?
May 17, 2009

AprilTwoCats
Gary I thought you were channeling Robin Williams on this show, talking even faster than normal, jumps of logic, unrolling one sleeve but not the other, then rolling it up again. Are you sleeping enough? It’s fun to watch someone that excited about life.

Nice to see a reasonably priced Antinori wine.

QOTD: I’m lucky, I live within driving distance of the store, so free shipping doesn’t matter to me. On the other hand, it’s nice to reward your long time fans with something besides an occasional wrist band.
May 17, 2009

Jeff Smith
Great Job Gary. Loved the pace of this show and love the fact you got 4 wines in there.

QOTD: It would be great for a coupon code once in a while. However being from MI I could only order non wine items.
May 17, 2009

Zino
Nice One. You nailed the Kanonkop and the Vermentino. I think Kanonkop are one SA’s best producers, the ‘Paul Sauer’ is also very good and sometimes outstanding. I’ve just got back from Sardinia and tried many Vermentinos. They didn’t blow me away but were consistently good, often having a floral nose, grapefruit flavour, a pure minerality in the centre, greatly judged acidity and a lemony finish. The reds from the south were even better, more structured and complex. The consistency of Sardinian wines through several regions, varietals and vintages really surprised me. Could go on more about them, but I won’t bore you. You should do an episode on Sardinian wines?

QOTD: Yes, free wines and shipping to all viewers in the UK on a regular basis.
May 17, 2009

Phil G
I feel like there are so many different types of Italian White wines and so many of them fly under the radar even though they often kill it. I think a big Italian White taste off would be a great show: 8 – 10 numbered brown bags in a blind battle royal. Nice.

QOTD – I would love special offers for WLTV viewers, and have appreciated them in the past. However, I do agree that it could get close to the line that you don’t want to cross (you don’t want to come off like Crazy Eddy – “You gotta buy these wines with this free shipping codes… it’s gonna be INSANE”). Maybe you could have people opt-in to a special WLTV promotions email list, and do something in there a few times a year…
May 17, 2009

Dominus
“La-La-La,” now these episodes are my favorite! Many references hit me along the way. “Peace, hippies” yes those were the most exciting years of my life. I loved the pace. Keep it up. And the Pinotage. Well, I’ve experienced SA Pinotage from 10 yrs ago and it was absolute garbage but now, I can’t wait to try it. Plus, a good Vermentino? Hallelujah!

QOTD: Yes, by all means. We hardcore Vayniacs know you keep the retail and WLTV separate as does Robert Parker which makes the two of you icons in your field but my suggestion would be to have a show maybe once a month where you provide Free Shipping. The title would be “Free Shipping Episode #1″ so any dweeb or lurker who came across the link would know beforehand what the show is all about. I’m there, so yes, let’s do it.

P.S. How about a shoutout to Jess Jackson who’s filly Rachel Alexandra kicked some major boy butt this weekend and review one of his premiere wines other than his famous chardonnay?

Peace My Brother and congrats to yours AJ on graduating from Boston College!!!!!
May 17, 2009

Dominus
Congrats on your graduation and Happy Birthday to Andrew W from Western Maryland!
May 17, 2009

Jeff R
Gary -
I didn’t mind the mixed bag of wines … sometimes it’s neat. Good to split up the everyday type of episodes (i.e. Cal. pinots or Burgundy).

QTD – I think it’s fine if you throw out an incentive every now and then (i.e. free shipping code). Your rewarding your viewer and I feel not pushing any product. Now if you had a wine for say $18 and you throw out “This wine is now $14″, I could see people not liking it and saying you are sales pitching on the show.

QTD #2 – I have no problem with the pace of the show. If you have a lot to say and the show goes longer, fine. If you breeze through the wines and the show ends earlier than usual, that’s fine too.

Indecisive in C’town.
Congrats to your brother graduating.
May 17, 2009

yowens
We’ve got a bottle of the that pinotage somewhere that I’m stoked to try. QOTD: Totally. Having watched almost EVERY episode of WLTV, I never doubt your objectivity in scoring. Free shipping would just be a way to score a couple bottles of the vino we love (ship to RI, please!).
May 17, 2009

bluna
QOTD – no just send love letters once in awhile : )

By the way I think the plant you were trying to remember was a pansy because that seems like a more common plant a child would bring to their mom.
May 17, 2009

RJaeger
QOTD: DO NOT put promotional material on the video. Like you said, there is a fine line that you should not cross before the videos are seemingly promotional. Maybe a promotional code on the homepage, but not through the videos. I, like many others, seek the advice and knowledge of the videos, not the retail side of Wine Library.
May 17, 2009

AUSSIE_SAMMY_S
Hi Gary Nice SHow ..AGAIN!!!!

In reference to the Shoofly Chook Raffle Chardonnay, you mentioned that it had a white meat/chicken character about it…Well in aussie slang ‘Chook’ actually means chicken – so there maybe a connection with the label and it contents???

QOTD…Do what ever tickles your fancy!!! I’m not bothered either way. I’m all the way in australia continuing to what your brilliant WLTV content
May 17, 2009

Sarah
Can you get Willamette Valley wines, there? I think you should invite someone from Oregon and have them pick up a few bottles, on their way out there – http://www.wvv.com/.

I love when you do a variety of wines – not all white or all red. Makes for interesting watching, BUT I also love to hear about the differences between different reds or whites, and realize that there are actually differences between them! You’ve expanded my palette simply through viewing! Thanks!
May 17, 2009

festriaqua
would love to see some free shipping codes for wl.com, will Definitely make me want to place more orders
May 17, 2009

pawncop
Another good show with good information. I did enjoy the faster pace, you cut to the chase and gave us the breakdown. Good job.

QOTD – I agree with that expressed full disclosure and it is an occasional event, I think it is a good idea.
May 18, 2009

Helge Hagener
Hey Gary,
I really like the pace. Keep that! And thanks for including pinotage again. The Kanonkop is still THE classic pinotage from South Africa. One of my favourite. Suggestion for one of the next shows: try “Silvaner” from Germany. That will be the next great thing after Riesling. Promised!
Cheers from Germany,
Helge
May 18, 2009

Antony
I’m an old school vayniac who, maybe for the last six months, has fallen out of my wine lib’ routine of watching an ep’ over breakfast. Possibly just too busy but I have caught up with most stuff through the archive when the schedule allows. Maybe also, being old school, I like it best when it’s just you in the thunder saddle doing your thing like only you can. I loved the Janics ep’, I loved the first mini-bar ep’ but today I just watched the show over breakfast and it was like the old days. I cannot believe you have done so many episodes now. Anyway QOTD – no. Your instinct was right to separate the sales pitch from the content. We know that the secret packs and so on must boost sales and you’ll plug this that and the next but it is a fine balance. It would be like whenthe Pink Panther suddenly acquired canned laughter. Love and respect, a.
May 18, 2009

Paul Marganski
QOTD: My initial thought is to say “No! Don’t sell out!”. But, this IS America and free markets drive our prosperity. So, I say go for it! Or, at least test it out and see what reaction you get. I say you go the “overly obvious” route to make it a bit funny/amusing, like some SitComs have with product placement in their episodes (e.g. 30 Rock).
May 18, 2009

stewart l
ENJOYED THE PACE OF THE SHOW- THAT’S THE TYPE OF SHOW i LIKE. aGREE WITH OTHERS, iF YOU found an interesting varietal with agood score, thae consider free shipping of it.
May 18, 2009

Karen
Hey Gary V.–Great to see you back in the saddle at WLTV headquarters! You are a traveling machine, though, so thanks for the shows from the road–although sometimes the camera shaking does tend to make me queasy.

About the special codes and free shipping–the psychology behind it is funny. As soon as you are showing that you are giving something, people will give TWICE as much in return! It drives me to the site (even when I can’t afford it) because I think to myself, G.V. is going the extra mile to make his fans feel special–the least I can do is buy 2 or 3 bottles to say thanks. From a business standpoint, I have no idea how much this sets you back (or how much you make for that matter). Thanks for thinking of the fans as much as you do!
May 18, 2009

Gibb Brown
Enjoyed the pace alot,i would love to see more shows like this. QOTD, I think pitches would be bad. To be honest i think the show is too pitchy now, espicially when you have guests on. I know you want to help young entrepeneaurs , but i think you water down your own product by pitching. Just my two cents.
May 18, 2009

CaseyLee
this is a classic WLTV Episode
finally
congrats AJ !
congrats GARY !
May 18, 2009

AMM3RD
Specials would be nice, but that’s not the sole of the show. If you are running a sale at the retail level it’s worth showing, but I would not make it a focus item…AMM
May 18, 2009

wayno da wino
SUUUUUUUUUUUUPER Episode!!!!!! Love the pace…..

qotd: Yo G, How ’bout, Buy ONE Vino, Get TWO FREE, plus FREE
shipping…….
May 18, 2009

Tracy Mercer
QoTD – Gary, let’s face it, the line is not blurry in the least. Everyone knows you are in the wine business and Wine Library is to a great extent, the product of your own marketing genius. I am sure everyone would enjoy and partake of some Wine TV specials . . . check my records: I am addicted to the Free Shipping specials and sales . . . as for your palate, it’s great fun to have access to your reviewed wines aka: secret packs, and then compare my evaluation with your own, so go ahead, take the plunge, especially when you discover an exceptional wine you really want to share with your peeps!!! See you soon, I hope.
May 18, 2009

Tracy Mercer
Oh yeah, BTW, daughter Miko and her friend had a AWESOME experience on The Thunder Cruise, can’t wait for next year’s program. Thanks, GV!!
May 18, 2009

Carlitos
QTOD. Dude! I’ll take free shipping any day! I don’t see how that’s pushy, unless you are restricting it to a few selections that you may need to move.

We’re still waiting for the Thunder Cruise only special offer too!!!
May 18, 2009

Chalz
Nice show, not as much thunder as some past shows.

QOTD: Why not put on the home page a code to enter for free shipping to all who view an episode and then order? Don’t mention it during the show just have it available for us who watch regularly.
May 18, 2009

BT86
QOTD: Gary, for the love of God. Please keep Wine Library and the show as separate as possible. The fact that you crap all over wines you carry, and give crazy love to wines you don’t carry sometimes, keeps the show real and shows that you really take an objective approach to the show. People that want free-shipping on the show are totally missing the point.

Plus you do free shipping codes every freaking day on your emails. Plus you don’t ship to Georgia!

Also, I think it’s pronounced “Pin-oh-tahj” and not “Peen-oh-tahj”
May 18, 2009

Jade from Portland
Gary,

QOTD: Keep them separate. I think the show will keep a better, more pure focus. There are avenues on the site for people to access the store and see specials.
May 18, 2009

Roberto
Gary,

long time since I have commented, only have time for you on my ipod, thus the lack of comments, however this one deserves a comment.

Please, please keep the two separate. You are already under fire from some (not that we should care) for rating wines AND selling them. I would love to keep that line clear by not mixing up the two… In the long run, it is better for all.
May 18, 2009

Bill the Wrist Watch Freak
QOTD: Don’t do it! I remember back in the day (ie. my lurker period) when critics threw the accusation of self-promotion of the business. As the great Billy Joel said, “Don’t Go Changin’”.

BTW, WL would have a customer for life if they’d get Joly’s wines in. Vive la Biodynamie!!!
May 18, 2009

oscar falcón lara
Good pace, it went like a very interesting class.

QOTD: I think it would be a great idea that every once in a while you send out a promo code and you could even link it to the comment, say for every comment on that episode you get an extra special gift or discount via email.

Good show.
May 18, 2009

Kevin K
QOTD: I don’t see why not. I think you’ve done pretty well with the secret packs in the past. Similar concept.
May 18, 2009

Fasciano
QOTD: People are thinking way too far into this one…free shipping once or twice a year? Why not?! Your niche in balancing sales and wine review has already been established. To discredit your opinion will take a lot more than a day or two of free shipping, you’ll have to completely change your personality and i don’t see that happening any time soon…keep crapping on those wines!
May 18, 2009

Slushpuppy
It’s your show Vayner, do what you know!
Smell it first. TR
May 18, 2009

boegemann
I’ve been away for awhile but couldn’t resist watching when I saw the Vermentino. Paired with pesto made from the first, tender basil leaves of Spring… this is classic Liguria!

I think the codes are fine as long as they’re not overdone. When linked to something you’re excited about in your personal life gives me the sense that you want to celebrate with me.

I like the pacing.
May 18, 2009

Phil Dunn
Gotta try that Pinotage. Just wikipedia’d it and am intrigued. Though sometimes that “nail polish” smell can bother me. At other times it doesn’t.

As for QOTD – It’s a good tool for converting new video watchers into customers. Most come into the WineLibrary world via the show.. so there’s definitely opportunity to make something happen there. I would guess that veteran watchers/buyers have it all sussed out by now.

I would refrain from over-hyping it, though. Quick mention and then move on to the juice!
May 18, 2009

brooke
i liked the pace of the show– no filler, no sports talk, just wine! the energy was up and that helped quicken the pace a bit. i like getting background info on the varietals and some historical info so that was a plus. much rather hear that then talk about the jets

QOTD: i think you could offer some discounts to the store and not be in conflict with the ethos of the show. maybe like you said a few times a year offer some blanket discount and give folks a few weeks to use it so they can wait until you review something that sounds good to try.
May 18, 2009

EdwardR
Gary – I’ve recently starting watching the show, I started with the episode with Kevin Rose from digg! I absolutely love the show!! You have opened up a new love for wine in my life and have helped explain the wine world in a language I can understand. I’m still diversifying my palette and trying to better understand the flavors and articulate them its still helpful to have someone with a passion and knowledge for wine such as yourself. Thank you Gary for every episode, I hope you make at least 1000 more!!! I’ll be there anticipating every episode to come.

QOTD – I currently have 12 bottles of wine in my wish list waiting for a free shipping code. I do not think a free shipping code every once in a while would hurt. I think a free shipping code is a present in itself (my 12 bottles would cost me around 45-60 bux to ship… that’s alot of coin!!!)
May 18, 2009

Andy & Edie from MT
Excellent show, loved the pace and your focus was laser-beam sharp! Need to get out there and try a Pinotage now.
May 18, 2009

Sasha M.
Another good show, great pace..Look forward to trying some of those varietals.. Never had a Pinotage.
I think the link between show & Wine Library can be made if it’s for the right occasion. No one is gonna think you sell out especially if they’ve been watching and know a little about you.
Keep it comin, Crush it always!
May 18, 2009

Jon Berry
I really enjoyed this episode Gary. Good info, and I’d love to one day catch a nose that reminded me of “Banana peel wrapped in bacon!”

QoTD: No! Outside of WLTV your very inspirational message to “Crush It!” involves transparency and passion, and above all honesty. Sometimes when I tell my WebDev / Internet Marketing clients about your show, marketing methods, and overall strategy their initial reaction is, “Yeah, he uses the show to sell wine from his wine store.” This suspicion will only grow if you start to mix the two. Obviously, us Vayniacs know where you stand based on your review of Shoofly Chardonnay…panning it just after telling us how much of it you are selling, and how people are searching for it on WineLibrary.com. I’m certainly not buying wine that tastes like chicken!!

Between the secret packs, email offers, free.winelibrary.com, and random Twitter promos and codes, I think you are doing plenty to take care of your fans.

Keep on rockin’ Gary!
May 18, 2009

Chris Hansen
Gary, You made the Wall Street journal Gaiter and Brecher list this year! They said you are, ” Wine geek of the moment. His upbeat, charming commentary at tv.winelibrary.com has made him a star and brought him a huge book deal. His many followers are called Vayniacs.”

QOTD: Keep them separate.
May 18, 2009

Jon E
If hell needs a name change I’d call it pinotage

QOTD: Anybody who says keep it seperate doesn’t understand our business and surely doesn’t buy from you, or perhaps care about money. Free shipping is good, always good. In the trade we’re business people first, selling more wine is what its all about. And thanks to this economy we all have to do what we have to do. The moral high horse is a lonely place where wine sales are rare and fleeting.

BT86-eat my shorts
May 18, 2009

purplejuicebruce
Gary, those of us who have watched 500 episodes or more have a pretty good idea of your business ethics. We know you sell wine on the internet and we also know you call things like you see them. I for one hope you make a billion dollars and buy the Jets.In these hard economic times free shipping for the Vayner nation is a plus. Thyank you for all you do.
I would like to see an episode about Cali Carignane and Barberas
Bruce
May 18, 2009

Wyld
QOTD: Dont you already sell “secret packs” and shirts and books on your show?

I mean here i am watching a show i love all the time… COMMERCIAL FREE. So when you pipe in about something, its cool, i expect a little bit of that, this is America. But one thing i never really thought about, but does seem lacking, is a few marketing ploys(or do i just see too many that yours seem few?).

But here is what i say, do what you want. Im not watching for free shipping.

Peace!
May 18, 2009

DanM
QOTD: I don’t mind the crossover from WLTV to WL business every once and a while. As long as they are not linked to the specific wines you reviewed that show or the last few shows…. Keep them open to any purchase.

It’s not like we don’t know you run a wine store.

On the other hand, you have made it pretty easy to find out when WL gives deals through a separate twitter feed or other things you (and WL team) have done. It’s out there.

And I say this from a state you can’t even ship to, which kills me.
May 19, 2009

AnthonyfromSocal
Gary,

Loved the show. I am new to the nation but an occational plug couldnt hurt. Look I bought 2 books already.

Looking forward to trying to catch up to all your shows.
May 19, 2009

YoungDave
Pace was great! AND it’s great to have you back in the thunder saddle.

QOTD: I think it would be a good idea to offer some incentive to WLTV viewers every once in a while. I DON’T think that it will be an offer that will force people to either watch the show or buy from WL, so I don’t think you need to worry about it seeming gimmicky, but it might be a nice perk for those who currently do, and have continued to watch your show for so long. Cheers, Big G, and CONGRATS TO MY MAN AJ!! (a fellow Boston college student… and grad!)
May 19, 2009

innA
I don’t remember trying a Vermentino – might have to seek that one out.
May 19, 2009

jeffe
GV, you’ve worked very hard to cultivate your credibility with your audience. Aside from the books (which are personal ventures, not WL product), the only other WL commercial connection you’ve promoted has been the secret packs. And I think everyone realizes that you’re quite obviously eating the margins on those, what with the discounts and free shipping.

As an NYC resident, I’ve ordered from WL several times — each time after hearing you rave about a wine. I figure WL’s discount prices, and the fact I don’t have to walk the streets of the UES for lord knows how long, more than cancel out the shipping fee. On a personal level, I’m all for free shipping anytime you wanna lay it out there (see my purchase history and your email archives for evidence).

But I fear that by announcing those sort of offers on WLTV you may lose cred points with viewers who don’t order from WL as a matter of course. Especially those in other countries (and states) that CAN’T order from WL.

So here’s my proposal: allow your audience to opt-in for the offers, and distribute them via email (please don’t make me use twitter). That keeps the commercial stuff off the main stage, but allows you to throw money-love to your fans that have self-identified as wanting it.
May 19, 2009

dru
Respect the line between entertainment and sneaky business advertising. On the flip side, doing 5 shows a week couldn’t be construed as marketing if you only gave out a couple shipping codes a year. Besides, you already do ridiculous things for publicity and a fan following (armbands?). Maybe just start putting free shipping codes in the mail with armbands?

In short, if you could actually ship wine to me, I’d be okay with OCCASIONAL free shipping codes or WLTV discount wine sales or something.
May 20, 2009

Ryan D
QotD1: Yeah don’t use the show to sell. A free shipping code once every 6 months wouldn’t hurt, though.
May 20, 2009

Jay Campbell
QOTD: No, beacuse you don’t ship to WA. Yeah, it’s selfish.
May 20, 2009

victor
Too bad you don’t ship to Canada… When is Wine Library going to open up a Canadian operation and where do I send my résumé? It would not cheapen WLTV in any way if you occasionally sent the Vayniacs a link to a special offer, maybe 3-4 times a year? Special occasion times, maybe centering around Birthdays, holidays, special or significant occasions.?.Whatever you want Big G. IT IS your show! Still pretty dry and thirsty up here in Canada, Cold, dry, bleak, thirsty Canada….
May 21, 2009

Pittsburgh Alex
the Free shipping code would be great play. Out her in PA it hard to find a lot of the wines that you taste, but still could use it because you can’t ship to PA. Stupid Quakers.
May 22, 2009

Grant
Happy to see a pinotage on the show again.

QOTD. No on the shipping code. I think you are right about maintaining a separation. The video project is all about the wine itself. Passing on your knowledge, experience and opinions should be the sole reason for the video project. If it prompts some sales for you, then that’s gravy. As soon as you start pandering your own wine on the show, it loses something for me. Motives become suspect, etc.

I may be in a minority here, but I watch this show for information on varietals, regions, etc., not to see what you like, and then turn around and buy it. Those people worry me (no offense intended).
May 22, 2009

Kathy Hughes
QOTD: Free Ship- No Brainer- Any time. Best, Naples Kathy aka Champagne Lady
May 22, 2009

Steak Monster
QoTD: Really I don’t think anyone would have a problem with free shipping, but it’s almost like overkill becuase we watch the show for the content, or whatever reason (crush on GV?).

PS. Was kind of distracted watching today because your shirt kept crawling.
May 22, 2009

Brad
I’ve never actually bought any wine online before, but if I did I would buy it from wine library, especially if you had a wltv discount!
May 22, 2009

Zipper Jack
QOTD – Gary, you are 700 shows in – you’ve establish unimpeachable cred – not an issue.

Pick a couple of WLTV reviewed wines each month that you feel “crush it” and/or expand the palate & do the free shipping thing. The dreaded lurkers (like myself) may just need a little extra coaxing to come out of the woodwork and get involved.
May 23, 2009

Ann
I’d keep them separate. I never would have watched early on if I had thought it was part of a retail pitch. Now I watch all the time so I might be okay with it, but what about all those other newbies who are just tuning in? They might feel like it’s all a gimmick to get them to buy WineLibrary wines.
May 23, 2009

Barstool
The intent of WLTV – as you so often state – is to help people explore their own palate. To explore, one has to taste. To taste, one has to buy wine. Why is there a conflict in encouraging people to buy that wine from you? In fact, since I moved to the non-ship-to state of Tennessee a year ago I have ‘voted’ with my wine dollars by refusing to buy the wine from the very limited swill-heavy selection available from local Memphis merchants in protest (that’ll show ‘em). I have made three trips in that time to Wine Library, an equal number to other retailers I like in Ca. and Wa. I’ve done so because it seems like the thing to do; patronize the people who go out of their way to offer something special. Anybody can stock a shelf with booze, not everybody tries to offer more.
So long as you remain honest in your tasting and don’t suddenly shift to review only wines that WL carries I see no conflict.
May 24, 2009

Dan-o
GV – I liked the show and the pace. I do like to lear about the varietals, therefore fun facts help improve the knowledge of your viewers. I like Pinotage, but have never had the one you tasted. I will look for it.

QOTD – You can’t ship to MA, therefore having irrelevant retail commercials would be a downer for me. This is a wine knowledge show, not an advertisement. I honestly don’t like the plugs for your book. You could do that plug once, but after that it appears self serving.
May 31, 2009

rowland
Hey gary.
Been working a lot, hustling, crushing it …
congradulations on the book, your brother’s graduation, and your very near first child!
ill be around,
qotd; do whatever, the secret packs have already opened the door anyway.
June 5, 2009

JayZee
Nice show – good energy.

QOTD: Well, I started watching WLTV when it began because of a link on your Wine Library website and I buy a crapload of wine from you guys so I have no problem with special offers intertwined with WLTV. After all, you often use WLTV videos on Wine Library’s website to pump a wine, so what is the difference really? It is not that I think WLTV is simply a commercial – I know it isn’t and I truly appreciate it. But I see no problem with a tie-in once in awhile. And you have offered free shipping codes to WLTV viewers before.

Congrats to AJ!!
June 7, 2009

the2urbs
dude, free shipping is good…

do a show once in a while & do free shipping on the wines on the show…

taste six you have had before & run with it…

I wanna see more Italian Whites…
June 8, 2009

Jayhitek
I like the fast pace. I was on vacation and came back to like 10 episodes in my inbox.. was dreading the 7 hours of Gary I was going to have to catch up on. I like what I am seeing so far.

QOTD: was there one?
June 14, 2009

chukhead-ted
hi gary, i think it is good how you keep retail separate from show content. thanks!
July 20, 2009

Michael Elkin
Gary,

Thanks for showing a new side of Pinotage (vs. the usual negative)… after watching this, I realized you REALLY know what you are talking about…