EP 952 Tasting with Tim Spear from Clos Mimi Part 2

Gary Vaynerchuk and Tim Spear conclude the tasting of the Clos Mimi wines.

Wines tasted in this episode:

2007 Clos Mimi Mcginley Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon
2004 Clos Mimi Mcginley Vineyard Syrah

Links mentioned in todays episode.


Latest Comment:

View More

luca bercelli

83/100

Slightly better than part one but someone should have told this guy that he was on Wine Library TV and not a visit with his shrink. ‘Put some strain on my marriage’. No one wants to know matey.

Tags: cabernet, california, review, Video, wine, wines

Episodes >


  • Wow… Mr. Spear is complex, I did not see him cherishing Gaga. I do love his love for Hockey and wish him continued tremendous success with his wines. I will look to visit that winery (if it is possible) in 2011.

    QOTD/Yesterday: I came a little late to the party but I would venture to say that Jamie L. would like rieslings from California and Ilya K would like Champagne and Martin B DOES like Super Tuscans. Just a guess for the other players mentioned, that would be the best I could do.

  • Anonymous

    Wait, he likes Gaga because she’s not from Europe? Didn’t see that one coming.

    Yzerman drinks Labatt Blue.

  • Anonymous

    What a chore this was to watch. This guy was nothing but pure ass.

  • Anonymous

    I think Gary should team up with Jon Bon Jovi to make wine for Brodeur as they are both Jersey dudes.

  • Agreed! Aglianico is an awesome varietal, but it’s gotten too little airtime on WLTV…

  • dcos-and-it-don’t-stop

    This guy kind of makes me think of Debbie Downer from SNL but without the laughs. I’m hoping its that he’s shot from running the NYC marathon. But if the marathon was all a ploy to help push his wines, you’d think he’d be more upbeat and show some enthusiasm. GV, this guy even brought down your level of intensity, which I thought could only be accomplished with Jet losses.

    Big props though for Tim’s honesty about the difficulties of running a high-end, boutique winery in today’s economic climate.

    Some good tidbits in this set of shows, but I’d have to rate it a PASS. I found myself nodding off.

    QOTD: You think any of these NHL stars drink icewine?

  • I suppose a penchant for Renoir could be a potential stumbling block, but I found the Gaga preference even more disconcerting…

  • Anonymous

    Strange Bird. Does this guy eat ‘mushrooms” with his wine? Don’t even understand how to answer the QOTD….uh, they all drink Mad Dog?…who knows…and who cares? I am sure he is a nice guy, but wow is he out there.

  • ALLAN

    A visit from Peter Sisseck would be nice.

    He’s cool and he’s danish, it’s win-win. 🙂

  • So true. BTW. That flounder looks amazing! How did you make it? 🙂

  • We always want free shipping Vaynerchuk. We are needy that way. ;-P

  • hmm, a private package not labled winelib with a customsdeclaration that it it is a gift might slip throu the customs tight webb 🙂 I’d love to buy two bottels of every 07 CdP in stock Is that OK? 😀

  • “Seriously, what is this guy withdrawing from? His hands were shaking uncontrollably.”

    How insensitive do you have to be to question something like that. He clearly is not ENJOYING his hands shaking. There is clearly something wrong, whether temporarily or permanently.

    In any case, I would choose to be decent and not berate someone based on a physical/apparent handicap. Him making a few dry jokes and comments about politics and American winemaking does not warrant anyone calling out something like this. At best it’s insensitive, at worst, cruel.

  • Anonymous

    Definitely not your average guest. Gary, I like that. It’s good to mix things up a little bit. Gary tells us to trust our own paletes and try new things. This guy is certainly strong in his convictions and trusts his own pallette. I think that just because Gary tells us to try new things doesn’t mean that all of his guests have to be the same. Tim prides himself on being an artist. History’s greatest artists and musicians are always famous for their eccentricities. So what if they freak some people out? They produce great results.

    Way to put on a provocative episode, GV.

  • LurkerKing

    Alas, I cannot E-Mail GV since then my identity would be revealed.

  • Anonymous

    Nice bike analogy, Mike. So true.

  • norcalking

    So let me get this straight; first attempt at Cab, first release, 93 points Robert Parker.
    Single vineyard, hand crafted California Cab. 75 bones. Expensive?
    The range is about six bucks to a mortgage payment or more.
    Money’s tight, but I think I’m putting that one on next month’s wine budget.

    QOTD; I have no idea. Hard to follow hockey much in sunny Cal.( For me)

    Very informative interview, but do loose the hat. To much of a John Malcovitch effect.

  • yea I loved the whole, I don’t know enough to tell you what the fed. or the Treasury does but I know enough to say Bush is to blame!

  • Hill11025

    Always love Gary’s guests; but Mr. Spear is, as one of the Vayniacs has already said, “off-putting” to say the least.

  • This dude lost me at hello.

  • 🙂

  • MTmax

    for sure. also, the aglianico featured on this show is to taurasi as standard nebbiolo is to barbaresco…i want to see taurasi ROCK GARY’S FACE OFF!!!

  • Alex T

    This episode got real, and I loved it. However, disappointed by all the hateful and ignorant comments. I imagine it takes a lot of courage to make wine like Tim does.
    Side note: As a musician, I love that Tim is a huge fan of both Opera and Lady Gaga. It’s great to hear such a variety in musical taste. It just so happens I’ll be performing in ‘La Boheme’ for the first time in January.
    Hope the Gaga label works out.

  • Interesting guest. More passionate than entertaining but it kept my attention. Yes, Tim is dark, Gary, not so much. I can’t say Tim’s a snob if he likes Puccini or admires the French any more than someone can be a snob for drinking wine over beer or preferring a French cool climate syrah to a modern aussie shiraz. This guy has HUGE balls for being himself and also telling it like it is. I haven’t seen a guest like this on WLTV. This guy is unique and I embrace that. If his wine is anywhere near as sincere as he is it should be damn good!

  • Email me. I won’t tell. Promise. *gives big glassy eyes*

  • Anonymous

    Awesome show Tim and Gary.
    QOTD – After a win hockey players usually wear Champagne. So they must drink Brunello after a win.

  • Hah! That… It’s ironic that that is what you see now when you go to the blog. The reason it was started (an the reason it will, hopefully, pick back up!) is the content farther down the page.In any event, I took a pretty standard approach – a fair amount of butter, and salt/pepper, oregano, lemon juice and sliced onion over the top. Stuck it in a fish temperature oven for somewheres around 25-30 minutes. Don’t quote me on that, though – this did happen in July. The funny part, as I noted, was that I had neglected to gut the thing altogether. The concept hadn’t even occurred to me.

  • Cood_man

    I think in the modern wine world there is a difference between WOW THATS OVER THE TOP!!!!( SWEET) and wow thats over the top??????? ewww) most of the wine world misses that.

  • Anonymous

    Thank You Tim, that was awesome. Laptop probs. stuck me viewing both of these ep.s late, but well worth it. As commented in pt. 1, I’d become a fan ,back in ’04 (Ohio), and this part explained how it’s not included under dist. I feel terrible for you, and wish you the best on getting through, passing on a vintage, moving product (which is probably developing beautifully), new enterprise/ market strategies, and even more importantly, health, and happiness for you and your loved ones. I will simply reiterate, that I am embarassed at the negativity on the board, particularly, as I’ve more than an intuitive feeling that many of the unsupportive comments come from quarters of people who are not even familiar with buying wines in the league, or caliber of which yours are, no doubt, members. My former state of Ohio, being a control state, most likely, only did have the Petite Rousse, which, again, sold through in days, annually. I’d had the privledge of being in places where I’d had customers for Cayuse, Negly’s La Port du Ciel , and even Chave’s Cuvee Cathelin, and the people that buy wines even 1/4 of those prices, like the Petite Rousse, tend not to speak with such an unabashed lack of couth. That much (even most, at times) of the public doesn’t know the true face of greatness in food, cars, art, taste, etc., without some ‘guiding’ arbiter to spell it out for them is commonly known by anyone who deals in worlds of high quality. That ignorance, bolstered by arrogant attitude is a lingua franca among the unwashed masses, is as easy to spot as the popularity of Goose and Red Bull drinking ( or that 4 Loco crap), Ed Hardy wearing douchebags.

  • Jennifer

    Still a class act, G.V. You’re a gracious man.
    -JenniferW

  • Wineytheelder

    A great interview Gary. Thank you for being more laid back and allowing Mr. Spears to speak his truth. An artist is seldom understood by the masses, as is evident here. For me, I wanted to pack up, head to Cali, and spend time in his company so as to better understand his muse. A man so passionate about art and music (loved the Puccini aria on this web site) and the history that has shaped the wine world for centuries to me represents a true renaissance from the doldrums of the world of instant gratification.

    To his nay sayers on this comment thread, eh…each to his own; interview preferences like palates are not given to herd mentality. You, Gary, showed remarkable maturity in bringing this to the Nation and it underscores your opening bite: “the internets most passionate” look at wine. Clearly Mr. Spears’ passion isn’t for everyone. Thank goodness. Ciao.

  • I’ve got a hockey game today and plan on popping some Champagne afterwards.

  • yusmo

    Great guest! I found Tim very fascinating!

  • Lucyfuer

    well i picture hockey guys pounding beer lots of beer , and you lost me at gaga i absolutely have no artistic resssonace with her , i refer to lady gag me , sorry not a fan,

  • Lucyfuer

    is that your real photo allan from denmark john lennon lover poser fake ? this is your non fan the girl you pretended to be a friend to your old and not so very attractive, and im glad i found out your a spy and not a genuine kind person

  • Lucyfuer

    wow so you probobly are on viagra thats why your so usually hyper are you danish , well cheerio like your clogs , over and out and i read write and can spell , your loss ,

  • John__J

    First off, part 2 was better than part 1.

    I only decided to watch part 2 though outta respect for Gary, and because I want to see every episode.
    I thought about what sort of comment to leave, but I don’t want to be rude. However, I can say honestly say now that I will never try any of his wines.

    if I answered the qotd, I’d say maybe an icewine?

  • JeJeMari

    I’ve never replied to a comment thread before Jason, but your comment was ridiculous and unnecessary. You may not have a taste for his style, philosophy, or political leanings, all of which is understandable, but to jab at a physical display- whether it was simply nerves or health-related, is immature. As for his appearance: An eccentric California winemaker? Utterly unheard of! Grow up.

  • ALLAN

    Picture is Don Rickles. A great American comedian. Spy??, you gotta be kidding me. Hope you cheer up soon Lucy.. I’m not a fan of you either, I don’t know who hacked your account, I only know it wasn’t me. I couldn’t hack a loaf of bread if I wanted to.!

  • ALLAN

    Someone pointed out to me that it was health-related on part one, I must have missed it too. Nerves?, i don’t think so. Some of the comments are a bit harsh, but we’re dealing with one of the few guests that will devide the waters for sure. Eccentric?, definitely. The hat was part of the act.

  • ALLAN

    I don’t think he gives a crap-load how he “comes off” to us. His passion must be wine and wine only. And family. I think he made that clear enough. Well, to me atleast. 🙂

  • ALLAN

    I tend to agree with you.

  • ALLAN

    Can anyone decode this load of bollocks ??

  • Anonymous

    To theWLTV community: Judgemental much? Hope Tim or any future guests ever read these comments.

  • Pizazz1@comcast.net

    Funny when he comments on Bush. As if he’s the catalyst for the hard times he’s experiencing. I wonder how he feels now that Obama has taken a strugeling economy and made it worse with bailouts and stimulous bull crap adding trillions to the deficit with zero results or job creation. Resulting in debt that ultimately will delay any recovery. Hey Tim, How’s that whole Hope and change thing working for you?

  • Phaser

    One reason I watch this show it the lack of politics. But freedom of speech is the greatest gift we have here in the USA. Good for Tim, stand up for what you believe, I do. But once you let one person spout dogma others will follow, someone will have to defend the other side, it ALLWAYS happens. I don?t want to find another show (because there is none worth watching but yours) I like this one. good luck

  • Anonymous

    I did not really enjoy these last two episodes and it has nothing to do with Tim’s politics.
    QOTD: WHO CARES WHAT THEY DRINK!

  • ALLAN

    This two-parter reminded me of a song by Prince called; “Controversy”. :0)

  • Anonymous

    Surprised that people are critiquing a passionate person for expressing their views. Isn’t the reason that most of us follow this show because of Gary’s passion. So you don’t agree with the guys politics. Do you like every wine you taste?

  • JrobRRV

    QOTD: Sine Qua Non, Screaming Eagle, Grace Family, Bond, Pride

    I cannot say I agree with everything Tim says or follows. He’s an odd fellow but so many wine makers are. I think legitimate bio-dynamic and organic systems really grow deep roots in the minds of people like this. A certain type is attracted to these ideas, which aren’t as intuitive and nature-nurturing as promoters suggest. The obsession on France is quite common, but he is so explicit and certain that it appears as vanity. I haven’t had his wines, but I’m a big Syrah fan. Cote Rotie, Hermitage, St. Joseph, Sonoma Coast, Mt. Veeder, etc. Santa Barbara isn’t my favorite source but some bottlings have been impressive. Some from Pax, Saxum, Sans Liege, and others. Still, I prefer cooler sites and wines like Failla, Dehlinger, Unti, and many others. Amarone is great, but we don’t look at California Syrahs for that. It doesn’t have to do with terroir or tradition or the “local.”

    He speaks of Randy Dunn as an inspiration while defending and promoting an 18% alcohol wine? That’s just one of the ridiculous things he says. Mike Smith (of Tamber Bay, Myriad, Quivet, etc.) has 18-20% prior to watering down most wines, a common practice probably with many of the over-the-top Rhones and Cabs, not just in California anymore. I’m not sure which is more desirable but still I can’t imagine why he couldn’t have picked earlier with reduced yields? I agree with some of what murso says below. Still, I was entertained more than educated, while typically I expect both from Gary. The rhythm of these two episodes wasn’t in sync with anticipated enthusiasm and passion we are used to.

Close

Not Subscribed to WLTV yet?

Never miss an episode and get notifications on the hottest wine deals!

No thanks.