EP 260 Looks great on paper

Today Gary tries 4 wines that look great on paper. Let’s see if they deliver.

Wines tasted in this episode:

2006 Allan Scott Sauvignon BlancNew Zealand Sauvignon Blanc
2005 Defaix Chablis Cote De LechetChablis
2005 Ercavio Roble La ManchaOther Spanish Red Wine
2003 Pikes Shiraz EastsideAustralian Shiraz/Syrah

Latest Comment:

View More

Flecko

I had the Ercavio Tempranillo a month ago and cannot agree with Gary. It has a awful artificial smell like somebody dropped rose parfume in it. It is very smooth to drink, too smooth for my taste. My first impression of this wine was not so bad, but I couldn’t drink more than one glas because the smell began to disgust me. In my opinion it is far from 90 Points. If you like to drink rose-water then I would give it 84P.

Tags: Australian, Chablis, New Zealand, red wines, review, sauvignon blanc, shiraz, Video

Episodes >


  • KenP

    KAHUNA, TheDumpPhase, great answers!
    QOTD: Erik (formerly of ChiPs’) Estrada’s ‘California Pines’. Slow dusty death at a high elevation. http://www.calpines.com/
    Just kiddin’. (Don’t wanna be sued.) Built a dream home, for feral cats and sheep.

    GV, great ep.

  • KenP

    KAHUNA, TheDumpPhase, great answers!
    QOTD: Erik (formerly of ChiPs’) Estrada’s ‘California Pines’. Slow dusty death at a high elevation. http://www.calpines.com/
    Just kiddin’. (Don’t wanna be sued.) Built a dream home, for feral cats and sheep.

    GV, great ep.

  • you recommended the 2004 vintage of the Ercavio last year, and I’m surprized you didn’t mention it. That one was a bit too sweet for my taste, though undeniably a good value for the money. Would you say this vintage blows the 2004 away? How does the flavor compare?

  • DK44

    Cool idea, great episode!

    QOTD: 2007 Cubs. Looked good on paper…………..

  • you recommended the 2004 vintage of the Ercavio last year, and I’m surprized you didn’t mention it. That one was a bit too sweet for my taste, though undeniably a good value for the money. Would you say this vintage blows the 2004 away? How does the flavor compare?

  • DK44

    Cool idea, great episode!

    QOTD: 2007 Cubs. Looked good on paper…………..

  • pegleg

    The last thing that looked good on paper?
    Probably Mark Mulder from the stl cardinals. Still waiting…

  • pegleg

    The last thing that looked good on paper?
    Probably Mark Mulder from the stl cardinals. Still waiting…

  • Steve-o

    QOTD: My ex girlfriend…I suppose the “on paper” thing is figurative…but yeah

  • Steve-o

    QOTD: My ex girlfriend…I suppose the “on paper” thing is figurative…but yeah

  • thescrewcap

    I bought a bottle of that Ercavio the other day b/c it looked interesting. Curious to see what gv has to say about it.

  • thescrewcap

    I bought a bottle of that Ercavio the other day b/c it looked interesting. Curious to see what gv has to say about it.

  • QOTD: Carlos Delgado on my fantasy team …. so far

  • QOTD: Carlos Delgado on my fantasy team …. so far

  • cdavis

    EAST SIIIIDE! Love it!

    Want the Ercavio tonight!! Huge Temp fan!

  • cdavis

    EAST SIIIIDE! Love it!

    Want the Ercavio tonight!! Huge Temp fan!

  • Norcal

    Ocean’s Twelve, baby!

    Looking forward to the Ercavio…

  • Norcal

    Ocean’s Twelve, baby!

    Looking forward to the Ercavio…

  • Canuckchuk

    Wow! Theme of the day so far on the thread: don’t do a wine-lover wrong when it comes to love. Hell hath no fury like a scorned wine-lover. etc., etc.

    QOTD: Damn those fortune cookies!

    And Gary, would you mind doing shows on wines from the following countries: Croatia, India, and China.

    Thanks.

  • Canuckchuk

    Wow! Theme of the day so far on the thread: don’t do a wine-lover wrong when it comes to love. Hell hath no fury like a scorned wine-lover. etc., etc.

    QOTD: Damn those fortune cookies!

    And Gary, would you mind doing shows on wines from the following countries: Croatia, India, and China.

    Thanks.

  • He who is loved by many animal

    Have tried the ercavio, but you now – I prefer the prima from toro 04. Same price I think. Oh, and try the Aalto 04 if you can lay your hands on some, A have 2 cases secured through futures, and it is fantastic! Spain has a certain style, but the Aalto wines (and also the Mauro ones from same winemaker Mariano Garcia) are fantastic! Do try them, they come highly recommended!

    Adam

  • He who is loved by many animals, but not so much human babies – they freak me out!

    Have tried the ercavio, but you now – I prefer the prima from toro 04. Same price I think. Oh, and try the Aalto 04 if you can lay your hands on some, A have 2 cases secured through futures, and it is fantastic! Spain has a certain style, but the Aalto wines (and also the Mauro ones from same winemaker Mariano Garcia) are fantastic! Do try them, they come highly recommended!

    Adam

  • Harold

    Nice to hear that the Ercavio lived up to the hype. I’ve had a couple of Jay Miller 90+ pointers and IMO he over scored all of them. Thanks GV.

  • Harold

    Nice to hear that the Ercavio lived up to the hype. I’ve had a couple of Jay Miller 90+ pointers and IMO he over scored all of them. Thanks GV.

  • MannyPants

    Nice one Gary. Really enjoyed this epidode. Way to bring it, although I believe it’s a tucan on the Fruit Loops box. QOTD: Mike Vick pre-Ron Mexico/Smoking a J on Myspace/Water bottle in the Miami airport/Skipping his meeting with Congress/Sponsering a dog fighting ring. Wow.

  • MannyPants

    Nice one Gary. Really enjoyed this epidode. Way to bring it, although I believe it’s a tucan on the Fruit Loops box. QOTD: Mike Vick pre-Ron Mexico/Smoking a J on Myspace/Water bottle in the Miami airport/Skipping his meeting with Congress/Sponsering a dog fighting ring. Wow.

  • Harold

    QOTD: Fantasy Football 2004, Kevan Barlow

  • RuralTom

    Greetings Mr V!

    Question of the Day: My previous cooking job…

  • Harold

    QOTD: Fantasy Football 2004, Kevan Barlow

  • RuralTom

    Greetings Mr V!

    Question of the Day: My previous cooking job…

  • Nice. Pity for the Pikes. My experiences with Pikes are very good. Their Shirazzes and Merlots (especially the reserves) are great. Quite Northern Rhone even: very earthy, backward, little bit serious, dry and refined. Never heard of the Eastside though, I’m gonna seek’m out.
    QOTD: CdP Chante Cigale 2003. Something in the nineties for Parker. No way!

  • Nice. Pity for the Pikes. My experiences with Pikes are very good. Their Shirazzes and Merlots (especially the reserves) are great. Quite Northern Rhone even: very earthy, backward, little bit serious, dry and refined. Never heard of the Eastside though, I’m gonna seek’m out.
    QOTD: CdP Chante Cigale 2003. Something in the nineties for Parker. No way!

  • Autoproxy

    QOTD – Law school.

  • Autoproxy

    QOTD – Law school.

  • MC Dubs

    QOTD: Wasting a keeper spot on Brad Lidge instead of Bob Wickman this year – doh!

  • MC Dubs

    QOTD: Wasting a keeper spot on Brad Lidge instead of Bob Wickman this year – doh!

  • Wine Lush

    QOTD: Buying a house….any house.

  • Lb in KS

    QOTD: My current job….which happens to be the same job I’ve had for the past 17 years. weird huh?

  • Wine Lush

    QOTD: Buying a house….any house.

  • Lb in KS

    QOTD: My current job….which happens to be the same job I’ve had for the past 17 years. weird huh?

  • GottaGoDrink

    Gary- Great show all the way around. I am holding a case of the ’04 Ercavio based on your Ep 160 review where you said you’d be very interested to see what it’s doing in 2-3 years. See, we do listen. Too hot to ship the ’05, however.

    QOTD- Brett Favre. He has all the records, stats, MVPs, a ring, and the smalltown kid thing, but he is a head case who refers to himself as THE BRETT FAVRE. Scary guy!

  • GottaGoDrink

    Gary- Great show all the way around. I am holding a case of the ’04 Ercavio based on your Ep 160 review where you said you’d be very interested to see what it’s doing in 2-3 years. See, we do listen. Too hot to ship the ’05, however.

    QOTD- Brett Favre. He has all the records, stats, MVPs, a ring, and the smalltown kid thing, but he is a head case who refers to himself as THE BRETT FAVRE. Scary guy!

  • KW

    Two good picks today – a white and spanish red. There are still reasonably priced good wines out there. How does the Ercavio match the San Felipe Cab you reviewed some time back? I bought the San Felipe Cab and felt it was a bit more fruity than I would have liked though overall quality was good for the price.

  • KyBoy

    QOTD: Billy Donovan…glad we got Billy Gillispie (any Ky fan knows what I’m talking about)

  • KW

    Two good picks today – a white and spanish red. There are still reasonably priced good wines out there. How does the Ercavio match the San Felipe Cab you reviewed some time back? I bought the San Felipe Cab and felt it was a bit more fruity than I would have liked though overall quality was good for the price.

  • KyBoy

    QOTD: Billy Donovan…glad we got Billy Gillispie (any Ky fan knows what I’m talking about)

  • manual

    QOTD : every day i check the weather forecast here in Chicago.

    nice episode Gary. great idea for a theme. was that a Real Madrid fan in the background?
    love the ’03 Ercavio. will be buying the ’05 soon.

    cheers!

  • manual

    QOTD : every day i check the weather forecast here in Chicago.

    nice episode Gary. great idea for a theme. was that a Real Madrid fan in the background?
    love the ’03 Ercavio. will be buying the ’05 soon.

    cheers!

  • QOTD: Admiral’s Table, Mackinaw City, MI

  • QOTD: Admiral’s Table, Mackinaw City, MI

Close

Not Subscribed to WLTV yet?

Never miss an episode and get notifications on the hottest wine deals!

No thanks.