EP 260 Looks great on paper

Today Gary tries 4 wines that look great on paper. Let’s see if they deliver.

Wines tasted in this episode:

2006 Allan Scott Sauvignon BlancNew Zealand Sauvignon Blanc
2005 Defaix Chablis Cote De LechetChablis
2005 Ercavio Roble La ManchaOther Spanish Red Wine
2003 Pikes Shiraz EastsideAustralian Shiraz/Syrah

Latest Comment:

View More

Flecko

I had the Ercavio Tempranillo a month ago and cannot agree with Gary. It has a awful artificial smell like somebody dropped rose parfume in it. It is very smooth to drink, too smooth for my taste. My first impression of this wine was not so bad, but I couldn’t drink more than one glas because the smell began to disgust me. In my opinion it is far from 90 Points. If you like to drink rose-water then I would give it 84P.

Tags: Australian, Chablis, New Zealand, red wines, review, sauvignon blanc, shiraz, Video

Episodes >


  • NathanN

    Great show! Being fairly new with wine this is how I usually decide by comparing recommendations, scoring and tasting notes and of course price.

  • NathanN

    Great show! Being fairly new with wine this is how I usually decide by comparing recommendations, scoring and tasting notes and of course price.

  • Andre

    QOTD: My mail order bride.

  • Andre

    QOTD: My mail order bride.

  • Lurkerdog

    QOTD: Well, I ended up with swamp land in Florida …

  • Lurkerdog

    QOTD: Well, I ended up with swamp land in Florida …

  • Kelly

    GARY PLEASE HAVE MJK ON THE SHOW

  • Kelly

    GARY PLEASE HAVE MJK ON THE SHOW

  • nougat

    QOTD: Every NY Yankee team since, what, like 2001. Go Mets!

  • nougat

    QOTD: Every NY Yankee team since, what, like 2001. Go Mets!

  • Anonymous

    QOTD: A couple of apartment listings in LA…before I checked out the neighborhoods… and determined that descriptors such as “affordable” and “new paint” aren’t the most important things to be boasting about when posting an apartment listing.

  • YoungDave

    QOTD: A couple of apartment listings in LA…before I checked out the neighborhoods… and determined that descriptors such as “affordable” and “new paint” aren’t the most important things to be boasting about when posting an apartment listing.

  • So a client of our took us to a really fancy restaraunt in San Fran. It is place called the Carnelian Room. We ordered a bottle of 1986 Mouton Rothschild Bordeaux. We thought that since it had the high price tag that it would be the bomb…We were comparing it a Northern California bottle of RUDD Cab that was 3 times less, and 10 times better…The Mouton was good, but not $900.00 good…It was a once in a lifetime experience but I knew in the back of my head that no bottle of wine is worth that much money…I you told me it was a $30-$50 bottle I would believe you…We all really loved all the wines that night but the RUDD cab was the winner by all 5 of us drinking…No more $900 bottles for me…I have learned that paper or price have nothing to do with quality or pesonal tasting experiences…

  • So a client of our took us to a really fancy restaraunt in San Fran. It is place called the Carnelian Room. We ordered a bottle of 1986 Mouton Rothschild Bordeaux. We thought that since it had the high price tag that it would be the bomb…We were comparing it a Northern California bottle of RUDD Cab that was 3 times less, and 10 times better…The Mouton was good, but not $900.00 good…It was a once in a lifetime experience but I knew in the back of my head that no bottle of wine is worth that much money…I you told me it was a $30-$50 bottle I would believe you…We all really loved all the wines that night but the RUDD cab was the winner by all 5 of us drinking…No more $900 bottles for me…I have learned that paper or price have nothing to do with quality or pesonal tasting experiences…

  • Muffinman

    QOTD –> this bottle of snapple i have in my hand atm, tastes a little off =/

  • Muffinman

    QOTD –> this bottle of snapple i have in my hand atm, tastes a little off =/

  • Carlitos

    Hey! Good to see that little brother is a Real Madrid fan! This year league champions! Campeoooneees!

    Excited about the Ercavio. I have some 04 but I guess I’ll have to look for the 05 too.

  • Carlitos

    Hey! Good to see that little brother is a Real Madrid fan! This year league champions! Campeoooneees!

    Excited about the Ercavio. I have some 04 but I guess I’ll have to look for the 05 too.

  • Ercavio looks terrific. will search for it. love the fruit loops tn’s, my fave cereal from childhood.

  • Ercavio looks terrific. will search for it. love the fruit loops tn’s, my fave cereal from childhood.

  • ChefD

    QOTD

  • ChefD

    QOTD

  • Gary, I’m pretty sure it’s a Toucan and not a Pelican. 🙂
    I cannot wait to try the Ercavio.

  • Gary, I’m pretty sure it’s a Toucan and not a Pelican. 🙂
    I cannot wait to try the Ercavio.

  • BWizzle

    Ercavio is a great value driven wine. I bought 6 of the Ercavio and 6 of the 2005 Guillaume Gros El Nino Loco that you reviewed and my wife and I enjoyed the Ercavio over the El Nino. Although after sitting the El Nino Loco tasted better. If you have a bottle with dinner 5 days a week you can not go wrong with this $8 dollar bottle. I have since ordered another case.

    I cant wait to get the Pasadoble when it arrives…two cases coming.

  • BWizzle

    Ercavio is a great value driven wine. I bought 6 of the Ercavio and 6 of the 2005 Guillaume Gros El Nino Loco that you reviewed and my wife and I enjoyed the Ercavio over the El Nino. Although after sitting the El Nino Loco tasted better. If you have a bottle with dinner 5 days a week you can not go wrong with this $8 dollar bottle. I have since ordered another case.

    I cant wait to get the Pasadoble when it arrives…two cases coming.

  • I really liked someone’s answer above (too lazy to go back and look): Star Wars: Episode I. I agree completely and think it’s a great answer.

    My QOTD Answer: Heath Shuler (Redskins #1 draft pick QB).

  • I really liked someone’s answer above (too lazy to go back and look): Star Wars: Episode I. I agree completely and think it’s a great answer.

    My QOTD Answer: Heath Shuler (Redskins #1 draft pick QB).

  • No, I don’t want to introduce myself! I don’t know anything about wine and I don’t even drink! I just watch the Thunder Show because it’s entertaining. I hope Gary won’t find me and kick my ass for being an evil luuuurkeeeer in the waaater. Please don’t hurt me!

  • No, I don’t want to introduce myself! I don’t know anything about wine and I don’t even drink! I just watch the Thunder Show because it’s entertaining. I hope Gary won’t find me and kick my ass for being an evil luuuurkeeeer in the waaater. Please don’t hurt me!

  • mcj

    QOTD: Bad Boys 2

  • mcj

    QOTD: Bad Boys 2

  • Donald Pipkin

    Do we need to get into the merits of Red Vines over Twizzlers? This is a classic east coast vs. west coast issue.

  • Donald Pipkin

    Do we need to get into the merits of Red Vines over Twizzlers? This is a classic east coast vs. west coast issue.

  • I just recently tried the Ercavio from La Mancha and it is excellent. And you can’t beat the price for such a great wine that I feel will cellar well for years to come.

  • I just recently tried the Ercavio from La Mancha and it is excellent. And you can’t beat the price for such a great wine that I feel will cellar well for years to come.

  • Valentin

    Sad, sad, sad… but the new york jets will drown. They are pussies! Next year they will be happy if they win more than 3 games. So sad, even a colleage football team can defeat them.

  • Valentin

    Sad, sad, sad… but the new york jets will drown. They are pussies! Next year they will be happy if they win more than 3 games. So sad, even a colleage football team can defeat them.

  • Chris Tessari

    You called the Pikes Shiraz focused and then 30 seconds later you called it not focused.

  • Chris Tessari

    You called the Pikes Shiraz focused and then 30 seconds later you called it not focused.

  • thefanjestic

    Qotd: Don Melchor – any year.

  • thefanjestic

    Qotd: Don Melchor – any year.

  • Dessert Wine Nerd

    Did Eric finally make an appearance on WLTV? Was that him writing in the background? Fun little episode. Nothing wrong with getting a steal on wine, or anything else. QOTD: The 2001 Seattle Mariners. On paper we should have destroyed everyone in our path on the way to a World Series. Have to give the Yankees props for sticking the wrench in the gears. I am rooting big time for Pinella to take the Cubs to the title though. Lou was the only manager who ever did any good for us here in Seattle, so Im hoping he can destroy the curse there. He’s going to be a God there if he does, too.

  • Dessert Wine Nerd

    Did Eric finally make an appearance on WLTV? Was that him writing in the background? Fun little episode. Nothing wrong with getting a steal on wine, or anything else. QOTD: The 2001 Seattle Mariners. On paper we should have destroyed everyone in our path on the way to a World Series. Have to give the Yankees props for sticking the wrench in the gears. I am rooting big time for Pinella to take the Cubs to the title though. Lou was the only manager who ever did any good for us here in Seattle, so Im hoping he can destroy the curse there. He’s going to be a God there if he does, too.

  • Adrian

    The ercavio looks tempting..on the Pikes you mentioned it was focus then later you said it was unfocused..hhmmmm

  • Adrian

    The ercavio looks tempting..on the Pikes you mentioned it was focus then later you said it was unfocused..hhmmmm

  • A thoughtful insight and ideas I will use on my blog. You’ve obviously spent some time on this. Well done!

  • A thoughtful insight and ideas I will use on my blog. You’ve obviously spent some time on this. Well done!

  • John__J

    qotd my previous car

    Gary next time you do some cheese and wine together on the show, how about comte cheese and vin jaune?

  • John J

    qotd my previous car

    Gary next time you do some cheese and wine together on the show, how about comte cheese and vin jaune?

Close

Not Subscribed to WLTV yet?

Never miss an episode and get notifications on the hottest wine deals!

No thanks.