EP 822 Chilean Carmenere Tasting

Gary introduces a grape that’s made a splash in Chile and brings some great value to the table.

Wines tasted in this episode:

Vina Chocalan Carmenere 2008Chile Carmenere
2008 Tamaya CarmenereChile Carmenere
2006 Vina San Pedro 1865 CarmenereChile Carmenere


Latest Comment:

View More

AndersN

Wrong video for this caption….its 821 showing Mott 🙂

Tags: Carmenere, Chilean, red, review, wine, wines

Episodes >


  • Cristian M.

    Yes, I'm from Santiago. What about you? Were you doing tourism when you came? Did you visit other places here?

  • My father-in-law has lived in La Serena and works at Cerro Tololo Observatory since 1975. I have been to visit a few times with my wife, mostly to La Serena, and the high Elqui Valley, but we have also visited Valle Encanto near Ovalle, and last time we visited her uncle working at Chuqui, and spent some time in the Atacama. Still so much moere to see. Maybe vendimia time 2011, we will share a glass?

  • admchin

    Camenere was actually the grape that got me into wine. My first bottle was chono 06 and I fell in love. When I started to try some Bordeaux (usually with about 10% of cab franc) I saw the similarties and then wine became a more common thing in my place.

    What can I say? I love the mouth feel. The nose on it is probably one of my favs.(mind I really just started gettting into wine the past year) I love the heavy dark berry play. Overall, I think its a nice varietal for other beginners to try out since usually its pretty easy to drink.(less tannins than other more popular ones out there)

  • and one fan from Mississippi who lives in Minnesota!

  • I've had several Carmeneres (I worked at WineStyles for two years), and love them! Love the cherry & raspberry flavors. Terra Andina makes a great Reserve Carmenere. A wine distributor once told me that when phylloxera wiped out the French vineyards in the late 19th century, the French sent their Cabernet and Carmenere vines over to America to graft with our vines, which allowed them to replant and fight off the phylloxera. The Cabernet grafted well, and the Carmenere didn't, so the French didn't replant the Carmenere and it disappeared from France for 100 years. Some American vintners found it growing in Chile 20 years ago, but the Chileans thought it was Merlot, and had it interplanted with Merlot which ripened differently. Once they separated the vines, Carmenere came into its own. Great story–can anyone verify?!

  • Cristian M.

    Sorry to reply to this post. The system didn't allow for more replies to the other one (probably on purpouse, to avoid boring the other readers). Great to know that you have been in la Serena and other northern cities, and also to know that your in-law family has ties with astronomy (another of my passions) Actually I'm an architect, and made my thesis about recycling an astronomy observatory in Santiago, which is now pretty much useless (Cerro Calan) to open it up to the community. Since he's nearby, ask your father in law to send you some bottles of MAYCAS wines (from Limari) that are excellent, specially Syrahs, Chardos and Sauv. Blancs. Vendimia '11… Sure !

  • Cristian M.

    Don't know about the grafting, but the last part of your story is very true.

  • Cristian M.

    Yes, I had a Falernia Reserve 2005 last year, and it was very good. But the next two vintages were not as good as that one.

  • That's pretty close as I understand it…The vine looks a lot like merlot, but the leaves change color, and it takes a couple of more weeks to ripen and should be harvested about the same time as the cab sauvignon. An ampelographer saw the differentiation in 1994 and had to go back through old texts to prove that it was Carmenere. I gather that it was always a finicky grape to grow in Bordeaux and so was passed over when the great grafting period ensued. I'm not sure how well the Carmenere grafts, but have heard that there is some growing in Washington and California now, and an Italian wine distributor I met says that there is some small amount growing in northeast Italy where it was mistaken for cab franc. This history of this grape is a great story, and its future may be bright as well. Interesting Cab, carmenere, syrah blends starting to appear, and last year's WS wine of the year Clos Apalta from Lapostolle was majority carmenere.

  • jayhitek

    QOTD: no story. sorry GV. I failed you.

  • Cristian M.

    BTW. Laura: I've also tried that Terra Andina Reserva “Grande Vidure” (the other name for Carmenere). It was the 2007, a steal for 5 dollars here in Chile. Very well made.

  • Visited Chile about 2 years ago…. http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/494018

  • heavster

    I've had 3 or 4: Concho Y Toro Diablo 07 I liked.

  • Greg B.

    Big G, Love the QPR wines, but I'd like to see some over 90 points by the you.

    QOTD: 1 – Concha y Toro Carmenere Diablo

  • Eric B

    QOTD: had one or two, the Santa Rita is good.

  • Douglas Oliveira

    My favorites Carmenère are:

    1.- Terrunyo by Concha Y Toro

    2.- Montes Alpha by Viña Montes

    3.- Montes Purple Angel y Viña Montes

    Greetings from São Paulo, Brazil.

    Doug!

  • mclurker

    Thanks for the yucks, Gary. I enjoyed the dialog between the Chile and Chocolate characters.

    QOTD: I've never had a straight Carmenere. I will try to find one, soon.

  • TDFord

    i have not tried a Carmenere but i'm going to see what i can do to change that.

  • Vineares

    QOTD : 0 Sorry bub

  • dann

    Had my first Carmenere at a wine dinner this past week. Crucero Reserve Carmenere 2007. I was super impressed with the bang for the buck. Will get my hands on the Vina Chocalan and Tamaya. THANK YOU Gary for giving us a $7.50 – $17.50 once every 5 shows! My wife and I each drink a glass of wine a night and $300/month is max for our wine budget.

  • plcb

    QOTD: Over the past two years, I've had quite a few Carmeneres, 5-10+. While everyone is out trying trendy malbec, I prefer carmenere. Malbecs are too dark and heavy for my palate. I've had the Tamaya, CONCHA Y TORO CASILLERO DEL DIABLO, OOPS!, and I few others I can't recall the names. In the cellar I have, Rayun, Root 1, Santa Helena Carmenere Colchagua Valley Reserva, and Terranoble.

  • plcb

    Concho Y Toro Diablo is a very good everyday type pizza wine.

  • QOTD: I've tasted them, but they've never really hit my palate to the point where I've started buying them for myself.

  • John

    I love everything about the Montes Purple Angel except the price…

  • I've probably had close to a dozen carmeneres. The one I've drank the most is the Terre Noble. My vote for the closest thing to drinking a bell pepper: Montes Alpha's Purple Angel.
    Far and away the best Carmenere I've had is the 2004 Concho y Torro Terrunyo Carmenere. I've had it a few times and it's great. I'd never blind it for 100% carmenere. After trying it the first time and being very impressed, I discovered Parker called it the best Carmenere made in Chile.

  • Totally with you on the Terrunyo

  • leif

    concha y toro castillero del diablo carmenere 6 euro supermarket nice food wine period…

  • Wow, interesting timing of this episode given yesterday's 8.8 earthquake in Chile… :-/ Yes, I've had Carmenere, before, during & after my trip to South America (where I drank the varietal) and really like it, especially the ones with green notes. I've maybe had 5-6 in all (not a ton). I'm a Cab Franc fan as well, Gary, so I dig the herbaceousness of many Carmeneres. I have the '04 Montes Purple Angel sitting in my wine rack, got it for a steal at a liquidator's shop here in San Francisco. 🙂

  • Mott is on with the #85! Newest episode and this one! You go Mott.

    QOTD: I have had 2-3 carmeneres. I know the last two I had where given as christmas gifts. The other was at a tasting. I dont think I have ran across one that was very green. The one I had last year was very velvety in texture from what I recall.

    Jason

  • waynoooo daaa winoooo

    Yo Allan, getta Grip………. :o)

  • Hermano, I hope that you and yours are OK. The AURA website says that Tololo is OK, so they must be fine up north unless they were in the Santiago for the weekend too. No word yet…

  • Just Jack

    Terrific no nonsense, down to business episode.

    QOTD: I guess I have to get a bit more adventurous because I drink a fair amount of wine, and I don't recall ever trying Carmenere. It will definitely be in my cart next trip to the shop though.

  • J Ford

    QOTD: Wow, just had a Carmenere for the first time this evening. Quite good.

    Backstory: Jose, who brought the wine to the party, received news while we were tasting that everyone in his family are safe and sound in Chile, with only some slight damage to furniture and such after the earthquake.

  • Oakmon's BF

    I had a 2006 Casillero del Diablo Carmenere last year. I definitely liked it.

  • Benj

    Love the straight-up episodes. Thought this would've been a great opportunity to talk a bit more about the history of the grape and its history in Chile, but all the same, really enjoyed it.

    QOTD: In the past 18 months I've had 3 Carmeneres (From Casa Silva, Casillero del Diablo & Echeverria) and 3 50:50 Cab Sauv / Carmenere blends (Arauco & Oveja Negra). Sadly, looking back over my TNs, I didn't really find a whole lot of love there. The Casillero del Diablo was good, as the whole range tends to be, but I find their Cab Sauv & Shiraz better. I should give the Echeverria another try I think. I had a Syrah/Carmenere blend of theirs that was excellent and exceptionally good value. But so far, it doesn't look like Carmenere is doing it for my palate!

  • Cristian M.

    Hey pal, no need to worry about your father in law. The earthquake felt very mildly north of Santiago, so I assure you he's fine. The problem is with communications. 12 million people using the cellphone at the same time creates a mess. Let's keep chatting or emailing (drop me one here) on monday, maybe I can help you with your wifes dad

  • waynoooo da winoooo

    Niiiiiiiiice Straight Forward Episode !!!!!

    qotd: Can't remember ever having a Carmenere…..

  • Cristian M.

    Keep looking Benj. Try “de Martino”, “Terra Andina”, or higher end samples from Concha y Toro or Casa Silva. I've tried great Echeverrias in the past, but not sure if they were carmeneres.

  • rdd

    Just a handful…attracted by the price, I am cheapskate…….20Dollarsomm.com

  • Among the Carmeneres I tried, these are my favorites:
    Los Elegidos Reserva 2007
    Panul Reserva 2006
    Errazuriz 2007
    Baron Philippe de Rothschield Reserva 2007

  • Jeff

    Being a wine buyer for a small store I'm starting to see more and more Carmenere's. I've tried a half dozen. I'm intrigued by their aromas which are often of roasted sausage or herbs. Good value play for most folks. !!

  • I've had a handful of Carmenere's, probably about a half dozen. None have been terribly impressive, but none were awful, I would say the one's I've tasted, and I can't recall the names of any at the moment, have averaged okay to good. They tend to remind me of if one were to move on the flavor and mouthfeel spectrum from Cab toward Merlot of heading even further in that direction, i.e. soft, smooth, round texture, darker fruit (I get a lot of plum, cassis, and even actual grape flavors), and softer tannins. Curious, Chile is the only place I've ever seen Carmenere, are these being made anywhere else at all?

  • yapdiver

    Had my first Carmenere about 8 years ago at a free Astor Wine tasting in NYC. I found it an interesting find then and have enjoyed a few bottles each year since. Now that it has found a market place I am seeing more selections on the shelf in the stores. If you live in NYC then check out a new store that specializes soley in Chilean products and it has a wine store attached that has a great selection of Chilean wines. Puro in SoHo. Small but unique so worth a look.

  • Waltraud

    Never had a Carmenere before; gotta try one soon!

  • E-Dub

    QOTD: A few years ago had my first Carmenere at Ibiza in Pittsburgh's S.Side. I was just getting into wine, but this was one of my AHA moments. It was on a tasting menu, served with 2nd course (Smoked Duck Breast), I don't remember the vintage but it was a Vina Santa Rita Single Vinyard. Simply amazing. The food was excellent, but the wine just awesome. I can remember just sitting back and thinking for minutes about the finish, cocao, minerality, fruit, just amazing. The rest of the dinner was actually ruined by how good that wine and pairing was. Got the waiter to bring the rest of the bottle out when we were done.

    Constantly looking for new Carmeneres since then. Honestly, few have lived up to the initial experience, but many have been very good, and all have been good QPR's.

    E

  • BurleyFox2007

    Greetings all,

    I experienced the beauty of Carmenere last night with some friends. Oddly enough, I hadn't seen Gary s' review until a few moments ago..serendipity is a wonderful thing. If you have a chance check out the Santa Carolina Reserva de Familia 2007, it was delicious. I am a newbie to the wine world and this wine was attractive because of the rating (91) W.S. and it's price point (17 beans 🙂 ). Thanks for listening and keep on tasting!!

    BurleyFox2007

  • QOTD: I “discovered” the grape several years ago, really enjoy it and have probably had a dozen, maybe more. Really, for QPR, you can't beat it. Even the so-so ones were around $8 so who can complain?

  • jcrazy

    I've probably tried around 10-15 and had the Vina San Pedro 1685 just a couple of weeks ago. I remember liking it a lot as I drank it with good friends watching action flicks. Maybe the tannins and oak went well with shiz blowing up.

  • murso

    QotD – it's late, and mind is sluggish right now, but Carmenere started coming onto our scene, around the same time I switched over to retail from distribution, 'round 97-98. I'd enjoyed the spice, and red merlot-like character of hte enry level offerings, which was most of what they'd opened te doors with. They (conservatively played) weren't gonna bust doors open on big investments/bottle w/ some 'new'thing' that noone'd ever heard much about. So, by the millenium, the one that I was really most impressed w/, overall was Calina -and if I'm not wrong, it was K-J's investment, and to support that type of product, was kinda anethema to my 'ideals', at the time, but I recall that I really liked that one, over the others. And THEN they dropped the price to crazy post-off prices, and the rest was, as they say, history!
    Also, Veramonte's Primus blend depended/exploited it to widely varying percentages of theblend. Some were really good, other years… maybe not so much.

  • HenryCan

    I've had Clos Apalta 2003 which I believe is a blend. An outstanding wine! I believe Camenere and Tannat will start getting more rhythm in South America.

Close

Not Subscribed to WLTV yet?

Never miss an episode and get notifications on the hottest wine deals!

No thanks.