EP 368 New York City Wine Tour

The Thunder Show goes on the road again on a wine tour of New York City. Gary’s first stop is Shelly’s and tastes some wine with Andre Mack.

Wines tasted in this episode:

Once Pinot Noir
2004 Sandro Fay Rosso di Valtellina

2002 La Spinetta Barbaresco

Latest Comment:

View More

John__J

Qotd: Antrim's 1844, over 2,300 selections and I'm surprised at how low their mark ups are for a restaurant

Tags: New York City, red, review, Video, wine, wines

Episodes >


  • JohnP

    Melbourne(Aus) via London(UK)

    great show gary, many of your medical viewers (traditionally some of the biggest wine nuts going) will have smiled at your inadvertent “back to back nebs” joke – “nurse give this asthmatic back to back nebs!” “will the 2002 do doctor?”

    QOTD Andrew Edmunds in Soho London – great and varying selection at almost cost price including half bottles – excellent for trying a bigger variety of wines during a meal. And of course the legendary Arches Wine Bar in Swiss Cottage.

    Questions related to this episode – vacuum sealing and wine by the glass effective? Especially with larger selections and hence slower turnover especially at the top end. What about these closed systems that allow a vast array of fine wine by the glass – Wonder Bar at Selfridges serves Chateaux Petrus by the glass! Good or Gimmick?

  • JohnP

    Melbourne(Aus) via London(UK)

    great show gary, many of your medical viewers (traditionally some of the biggest wine nuts going) will have smiled at your inadvertent “back to back nebs” joke – “nurse give this asthmatic back to back nebs!” “will the 2002 do doctor?”

    QOTD Andrew Edmunds in Soho London – great and varying selection at almost cost price including half bottles – excellent for trying a bigger variety of wines during a meal. And of course the legendary Arches Wine Bar in Swiss Cottage.

    Questions related to this episode – vacuum sealing and wine by the glass effective? Especially with larger selections and hence slower turnover especially at the top end. What about these closed systems that allow a vast array of fine wine by the glass – Wonder Bar at Selfridges serves Chateaux Petrus by the glass! Good or Gimmick?

  • It was very interesting to see another wine professional’s technique – the sniff, the taste, how he aerates the wine and chews it rather than doing the GV “bird sounds” and his spitting form.

    QOTD: Can’t afford restaurants, but there’s a great BYO place nearbye: the Blue Point Grill, that has great seafood. Best meal: Small Gully The Formula ’03 with mussels in white wine sauce and a tuna steak. Wine glasses are terrible, though. Next time I’m bringing my own.

  • It was very interesting to see another wine professional’s technique – the sniff, the taste, how he aerates the wine and chews it rather than doing the GV “bird sounds” and his spitting form.

    QOTD: Can’t afford restaurants, but there’s a great BYO place nearbye: the Blue Point Grill, that has great seafood. Best meal: Small Gully The Formula ’03 with mussels in white wine sauce and a tuna steak. Wine glasses are terrible, though. Next time I’m bringing my own.

  • Nice episode 🙂

    QOTD: Sportsman’s. It’s a great wine shop and restaurant here in AZ. They have awesome salads and sandwiches, and a lovely selection of wines by the glass, of course there’s also the option of pulling a bottle out of the store and having them pop it right there for you to drink.

  • Nice episode 🙂

    QOTD: Sportsman’s. It’s a great wine shop and restaurant here in AZ. They have awesome salads and sandwiches, and a lovely selection of wines by the glass, of course there’s also the option of pulling a bottle out of the store and having them pop it right there for you to drink.

  • salvatore

    Wine bars ok

    Video———muhhhhhhhhh wasting my time; called dumbing down America!

  • salvatore

    Wine bars ok

    Video———muhhhhhhhhh wasting my time; called dumbing down America!

  • Anonymous

    QOTD: I gotta go with my current place of work: TASCA WINE BAR in Los Angeles. Fantastic by-the-glass selection (including 3-4 additional daily specials), decent bottle selection, and great old-world comfort food presented in both small and large plates. For anyone in the LA area: stop in, say hello to Dave (me), and enjoy some good wine and good food.

  • YoungDave

    QOTD: I gotta go with my current place of work: TASCA WINE BAR in Los Angeles. Fantastic by-the-glass selection (including 3-4 additional daily specials), decent bottle selection, and great old-world comfort food presented in both small and large plates. For anyone in the LA area: stop in, say hello to Dave (me), and enjoy some good wine and good food.

  • Awesome episode!

    QOTD: WISH Restaurant here in Toronto. Great little place to have wine by the glass and a decent selection of wines by the bottle for a little restaurant.

  • Awesome episode!

    QOTD: WISH Restaurant here in Toronto. Great little place to have wine by the glass and a decent selection of wines by the bottle for a little restaurant.

  • Ryan D

    QotD: Posted this on the forums. My favorite currently is a local restaurant called Prime 15 in Ringwood, NJ. The food is only so-so [steak house, steak is okay, ribs are good, everything else is meh], and the service stinks [but no OMG we’re leaving bad]… but the wine list is surprisingly decent and VERY reasonably priced, in some cases below market.

  • Ryan D

    QotD: Posted this on the forums. My favorite currently is a local restaurant called Prime 15 in Ringwood, NJ. The food is only so-so [steak house, steak is okay, ribs are good, everything else is meh], and the service stinks [but no OMG we’re leaving bad]… but the wine list is surprisingly decent and VERY reasonably priced, in some cases below market.

  • Pardus

    QOTD: Bilbo Baggin’s Wine Cafe and Restaurant in Alexandria, Virginia

  • Pardus

    QOTD: Bilbo Baggin’s Wine Cafe and Restaurant in Alexandria, Virginia

  • B-727

    QotD: My favorite restaurant to drink wine at is (1) my favorite restaurant — Le Voltaire in Omaha — and (2) they let me bring my own wine, so I get the best of food and I’m not limited to any place’s wine list.

  • B-727

    QotD: My favorite restaurant to drink wine at is (1) my favorite restaurant — Le Voltaire in Omaha — and (2) they let me bring my own wine, so I get the best of food and I’m not limited to any place’s wine list.

  • SaraMHCRU

    great episode. there’s a great new place in New Brunswick with a fabulous wine list & tapas menu – Daryl Wine Bar (www.darylwinebar.com). they do 2, 4, and 6 ounce glasses of wine, and if you really like something they also have a shop attached and you can buy the bottles at retail price. awesome.

  • SaraMHCRU

    great episode. there’s a great new place in New Brunswick with a fabulous wine list & tapas menu – Daryl Wine Bar (www.darylwinebar.com). they do 2, 4, and 6 ounce glasses of wine, and if you really like something they also have a shop attached and you can buy the bottles at retail price. awesome.

  • KNode

    QOTD: Unless it’s a special occasion I usually don’t order wine at restaurants (mainly because I know how ridiculous the markup is). But I have enjoyed the wine list at The Grape in Dallas on more than one occasion, so due to my limited experiences I will say that one.

  • KNode

    QOTD: Unless it’s a special occasion I usually don’t order wine at restaurants (mainly because I know how ridiculous the markup is). But I have enjoyed the wine list at The Grape in Dallas on more than one occasion, so due to my limited experiences I will say that one.

  • QOTD: How can there be any answer other than Bern’s Steakhouse in Tampa.

    Silly rabbit.

  • QOTD: How can there be any answer other than Bern’s Steakhouse in Tampa.

    Silly rabbit.

  • Bill H

    love the concept this week. have Mott link up the restaurants though.

    QOTD – probably Sel de la Terre (Boston), but I’ve been finding some gems lately at some of the small Italian restaurants in the North End

  • Bill H

    love the concept this week. have Mott link up the restaurants though.

    QOTD – probably Sel de la Terre (Boston), but I’ve been finding some gems lately at some of the small Italian restaurants in the North End

  • JimVarney01

    VERY cool ep. Big ups to Andre Mack and Sideshow Mark for their help with this episode!!!

    QOTD: Mosaic in downtown DEEEETROIT! I haven’t really been to a whole lot of ‘wine’ restaurants… mostly just decent restaurants that serve wine. 95% of my wine is consumed at home or at friend’s houses.

  • JimVarney01

    VERY cool ep. Big ups to Andre Mack and Sideshow Mark for their help with this episode!!!

    QOTD: Mosaic in downtown DEEEETROIT! I haven’t really been to a whole lot of ‘wine’ restaurants… mostly just decent restaurants that serve wine. 95% of my wine is consumed at home or at friend’s houses.

  • VinoVixen

    Great show. Looking forward to more NYC wine tastings!
    QOTD: Commonwealth Market, Charlotte NC. They have a great wine selection…thanks Matt…eclectic crowd and you can get a bottle and sit outside and enjoy 🙂

  • VinoVixen

    Great show. Looking forward to more NYC wine tastings!
    QOTD: Commonwealth Market, Charlotte NC. They have a great wine selection…thanks Matt…eclectic crowd and you can get a bottle and sit outside and enjoy 🙂

  • Soldaddy

    nice road show….you gonna start appraising furniture next……

    Italian food and wine….always my favorite…

  • Soldaddy

    nice road show….you gonna start appraising furniture next……

    Italian food and wine….always my favorite…

  • Iron Man

    GV, so did Mark E’s tasting note was deleted because he gave Rubicon a 98-pointer!! I see how you are GV, I see how you are!!!!

    btw, once had a cab by the glass at…some Italian joint, I had to ask what it was…turns out it was a Mondavi, but the waiter couldn’t tell me if it was the $5 Mondavi, the regular cab, the reserve or the Oakville? best glass I ever had from a restuarant though without ordering a bottle.

  • Iron Man

    GV, so did Mark E’s tasting note was deleted because he gave Rubicon a 98-pointer!! I see how you are GV, I see how you are!!!!

    btw, once had a cab by the glass at…some Italian joint, I had to ask what it was…turns out it was a Mondavi, but the waiter couldn’t tell me if it was the $5 Mondavi, the regular cab, the reserve or the Oakville? best glass I ever had from a restuarant though without ordering a bottle.

  • Lb in KS

    Gotta say, G…. I’m diggin’ on these road shows. VERY interesting…thank you

  • Lb in KS

    Gotta say, G…. I’m diggin’ on these road shows. VERY interesting…thank you

  • QOTD: In NYC, probably Gramercy Tavern. Also Del Posto. And in the dirty JERZ, Roots in Summit is pretty decent. They even have a few WINTAGE ports by the glass.

  • QOTD: In NYC, probably Gramercy Tavern. Also Del Posto. And in the dirty JERZ, Roots in Summit is pretty decent. They even have a few WINTAGE ports by the glass.

  • Mott T Hoople

    Del Posto has what I consider a great deal (for upscale/NYC/celebrity chef) – eat a 4-course dinner at the “enoteca” (bar), and for $19 you get a wine pairing with each course. The wine is all Italian, and perfect with the food.

  • Grasshopper

    Great EP GV, love the field trips and hope you do many more….

    Flavor Pops – frozen ice in a plastic tube…)

    QOTD – have to say my own kitchen. Food is great and the wine is much cheaper than restaruants and usually much better!!! I hate the restaruant mark up game!!!!

    Hopper

  • Mott T Hoople

    Del Posto has what I consider a great deal (for upscale/NYC/celebrity chef) – eat a 4-course dinner at the “enoteca” (bar), and for $19 you get a wine pairing with each course. The wine is all Italian, and perfect with the food.

  • Grasshopper

    Great EP GV, love the field trips and hope you do many more….

    Flavor Pops – frozen ice in a plastic tube…)

    QOTD – have to say my own kitchen. Food is great and the wine is much cheaper than restaruants and usually much better!!! I hate the restaruant mark up game!!!!

    Hopper

  • Jim Sargent

    QOTD: Croma and Papa Razzi in Boston.

    I dig the thunder show on the road.

  • Jim Sargent

    QOTD: Croma and Papa Razzi in Boston.

    I dig the thunder show on the road.

  • Jayhitek

    QOTD: There was this bar in San Diego I went to one time that only sold wine. It was amazing. There were like 8 of us and like 8 different bottles of wine. I was black out drunk 2 hours later but what a great time.

    I think I heard the place has since closed. Bummer.

  • Jayhitek

    QOTD: There was this bar in San Diego I went to one time that only sold wine. It was amazing. There were like 8 of us and like 8 different bottles of wine. I was black out drunk 2 hours later but what a great time.

    I think I heard the place has since closed. Bummer.

  • give Mark E a job! too funny.

    fave restaurant to drink wine in, in San Fran –> Plumpjack’s, Absinthe, Slanted Door; in NYC –> Gramercy Tavern; in Boston –> Troquet

  • give Mark E a job! too funny.

    fave restaurant to drink wine in, in San Fran –> Plumpjack’s, Absinthe, Slanted Door; in NYC –> Gramercy Tavern; in Boston –> Troquet

  • Ricky B.

    QOTD- Veritas

  • Ricky B.

    QOTD- Veritas

Close

Not Subscribed to WLTV yet?

Never miss an episode and get notifications on the hottest wine deals!

No thanks.